My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Book Recommendations

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners.  Since MFM launched in January of 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest...

Episodes 1,279
Books 770

Recently mentioned

Latest Recommendations

Apples to Oregon: Being the (Slightly) True Narrative of How a Brave Pioneer Father Brought Apples, Peaches, Pears, Plums, Grapes, and Cherries (and Children) Across the Plains (Anne Schwartz Books) cover

Apples to Oregon

Deborah Hopkinson

Mentioned 1 month ago

534 - Think About the Simulation

They introduced the book as a children's story about a 1800s Midwestern pioneer family traveling west, loosely inspired by Johnny Appleseed.

If you were a kid in the 90s, and in elementary school, a teacher read you a book about a family of pioneers. ... It's called Apples to Oregon by a writer named Deborah Hopkinson, and it follows an 1800s Midwestern family in their westward journey.

Buy on Amazon
Survivor of the Killing Fields cover

Survivor of the Killing Fields

Haing S. Ngor

Mentioned 1 month ago

534 - Think About the Simulation

They noted that a book titled The Killing Fields had been written and served as the source material for the film about the Cambodian genocide.

They had written the book, The Killing Fields.

Buy on Amazon
Death in the City of Light: The Serial Killer of Nazi-Occupied Paris cover

Death in the City of Light

David King

Mentioned 1 month ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 98: Grasp It

The hosts noted that the book covered the dark, twisted tale of Marcel Petiot, providing location maps of Paris and details of his meetings, victims, and trial.

I came across a book in my local library called Death in the City of Light, the serial killer of Nazioccupied Paris. What a dark, twisted tale and man. The book provided location maps in Paris, including the house that neighbors reported burning, which led to Petrois being found out and arrested. The book also covers his meetings with specific victims and how he manipulated them to come to his home in the first place. It also covers the trial of Petrois, which was one of the most frustrating reads I've ever had to get through.

Buy on Amazon
Drawn to Injustice: The Wrongful Conviction of Timothy Masters cover

Drawn to Injustice

Timothy Masters

Mentioned 1 month ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 98: Grasp It

The episode mentioned that Timothy Masters authored a book recounting his experience of being tried, imprisoned, and ultimately exonerated for Peggy Hetrick's murder.

Timothy Masters wrote a book detailing his experience being tried, jailed, and exonerated for Peggy's murder titled Drawn to Injustice, the Wrongful Conviction of Timothy Masters.

Buy on Amazon
The Woman They Could Not Silence: One Woman, Her Incredible Fight for Freedom, and the Men Who Tried to Make Her Disappear (True Story of the Historical Battle for Women's and Mental Health Rights) cover

The Woman They Could Not Silence

Kate Moore

Mentioned 2 months ago

533 - An Exercise in Frustration

The hosts highlighted Kate Moore's 2021 book, noting it revived interest in Elizabeth Packard's story and contributed to recent mentalhealth awareness.

Here's Kate Moore's book, she's an amazing author, oh yeah the one they could not silence, very cool.

Buy on Amazon
The Flowers in the Attic Saga (Boxed Set): Flowers in the Attic/Petals on the Wind; If There Be Thorns/Seeds of Yesterday; Garden of Shadows (Dollanganger) cover

The Flowers in the Attic Saga (Boxed Set)

V.C. Andrews

Mentioned 2 months ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 97: The Hague

They referred to *Flowers in the Attic* as a V.C.Andrews book, calling it problematic and discussing its controversial content.

there's a V.C. Andrews book. Flowers in the Attic? No. It's a problematic book that they talked about and they said it was controversial.

Buy on Amazon
When a Killer Calls: A Haunting Story of Murder, Criminal Profiling, and Justice in a Small Town (Cases of the FBI's Original Mindhunter, 2) cover

When a Killer Calls

John E. Douglas

Mentioned 2 months ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 97: The Hague

They mentioned that there is a book called *Mindhunter* which the case or show was based on.

there is a book called Mindhunter and that's what it's based on.

Buy on Amazon
ShadowMan: An Elusive Psycho Killer and the Birth of FBI Profiling cover

ShadowMan

Ron Franscell

Mentioned 2 months ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 97: The Hague

The hosts said Ron Franshell had written the book *ShadowMan* about the case and the birth of FBI profiling, noting it sounded interesting to check out.

there are no case updates, but in January of 2022, journalist and author Ron Franshell wrote the book Shadow Man, an elusive psycho killer and the birth of FBI profiling about this case and the role it played in the FBI's first criminal profile, which I think is so interesting. We should all check that out.

Buy on Amazon
Nancy Drew Starter Set - Books 1-5 cover

Nancy Drew Starter Set - Books 1-5

Carolyn Keene

Mentioned 2 months ago

532 - We’re Being Artists Here

The hosts explained that the original 1930s Nancy Drew novel entered the public domain and they had annotated it for a $10 purchase.

Nancy Drew went public domain in January, and nobody is talking about what that actually means. The version of Nancy Drew that most of us grew up with, the 1959 version, is not the original version. As of January 2026, that original text is free. It's public domain. So I annotated it. The link is in my bio. Wow. It's $10.

Buy on Amazon
Shakespeare Comes to Broadmoor: The Actors are Come Hither' - The Performance of Tragedy in a Secure Psychiatric Hospital cover

Shakespeare Comes to Broadmoor

Murray Cox

Mentioned 2 months ago

532 - We’re Being Artists Here

They noted that the primary source for the episode was the book Shakespeare Comes to Broadmoor compiled by Dr. Murray Cox.

The main source for this story is a book called Shakespeare Comes to Broadmoor, which was compiled by the doctor who spearheaded this program, Dr. Murray Cox.

Buy on Amazon
Parts Work: An Illustrated Guide to Your Inner Life cover

Parts Work

Tom Holmes

Mentioned 2 months ago

532 - We’re Being Artists Here

They referred to a book titled Parts Work while discussing therapeutic concepts.

the book's called Parts Work.

Buy on Amazon
The Blind Side: Evolution of a Game cover

The Blind Side

Michael Lewis

Mentioned 2 months ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 96: Live at the Hard Rock in Orlando

A brief reference was made to "The Blind Side" as a comparison while discussing a sensational story.

the blind side

Buy on Amazon

Most Recommended

Black Mass: The Irish Mob, The FBI and A Devil's Deal Cover

Dick Lehr

Black Mass

The Irish Mob, The FBI and A Devil's Deal

The listener mentioned reading numerous books and watching documentaries about Whitey Bulger after she was almost chosen for his jury trial, due to her prior connection to the courthouse.

"

So you're throwing your mom under the bus. Anyway, stay sexy and always sit in the back row.

— Episode: MFM Minisode 325

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: MFM Minisode 325

The listener mentioned reading numerous books and watching documentaries about Whitey Bulger after she was almost chosen for his jury trial, due to her prior connection to the courthouse.

"

So you're throwing your mom under the bus. Anyway, stay sexy and always sit in the back row.

I still can't tell how I feel about it to this day.

I was torn.

I noticed that I requested my presence in Boston, but I was living in, fuck, I hate this word, Worchester.

Then it hit me. Whitey fucking Bolger was standing directly across from me.

The Twelfth Victim: The Innocence of Caril Fugate in the Starkweather Murder Rampage Cover

John Stevens Berry

The Twelfth Victim

The Innocence of Caril Fugate in the Starkweather Murder Rampage

It was mentioned as a book that inspired a Showtime series about Carol Ann Fugate, and the Starkweather case, which was reinterpreted in a new light.

"

It's based on the book, The Twelfth Victim.

— Episode: 371 - Upset at the Air

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 371 - Upset at the Air

It was mentioned as a book that inspired a Showtime series about Carol Ann Fugate, and the Starkweather case, which was reinterpreted in a new light.

"

It's based on the book, The Twelfth Victim.

Wildcat: A Forbidden Sports Romance (Wildcat Hockey Book 1) Cover

Rebecca Jenshak

Wildcat

A Forbidden Sports Romance (Wildcat Hockey Book 1)

It was used as the primary source for the episode's story about Pearl Hart, which was said to be the most factual biography of her available due to her spreading misinformation.

"

This book seems to be the most comprehensive and factual biography of Pearl Hart that's out there because there's a lot of misinformation that she herself spread.

— Episode: 370 - Necessary Yelling

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 370 - Necessary Yelling

It was used as the primary source for the episode's story about Pearl Hart, which was said to be the most factual biography of her available due to her spreading misinformation.

"

This book seems to be the most comprehensive and factual biography of Pearl Hart that's out there because there's a lot of misinformation that she herself spread.

Buffalo is considered, quote, one of the roughest and most dangerous towns in America.

the vast majority of women in the 19th century did not have sexual relations outside of marriage. They did not smoke and they certainly did not use opium and morphine. They did not wear men's clothing, ride a straddle or carry six shooters.

Pearl Hart broke all these taboos and then some. She swore, smoked, drank, robbed, rode hard, broke jail and used men with abandon.

Wildcat: A Forbidden Sports Romance (Wildcat Hockey Book 1) Cover

Rebecca Jenshak

Wildcat

A Forbidden Sports Romance (Wildcat Hockey Book 1)

It was described as the most comprehensive and factual biography of Pearl Hart, which was important because she often spread misinformation about herself.

"

Like I said, the main source used in today's episode is the book Wildcat by John Boasnecker.

— Episode: 370 - Necessary Yelling

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 370 - Necessary Yelling

It was described as the most comprehensive and factual biography of Pearl Hart, which was important because she often spread misinformation about herself.

"

Like I said, the main source used in today's episode is the book Wildcat by John Boasnecker.

This book seems to be the most comprehensive and factual biography of Pearl Hart that's out there because there's a lot of misinformation that she herself spread.

So even her Wikipedia isn't completely true. So this book Wildcat is the best.

Buffalo is considered, quote, one of the roughest and most dangerous towns in America.

It is sewn with saloons and the Irish longshoremen love nothing more than a fight. And the quote, prostitutes, numbered in the hundreds.

Wildcat: A Forbidden Sports Romance (Wildcat Hockey Book 1) Cover

Rebecca Jenshak

Wildcat

A Forbidden Sports Romance (Wildcat Hockey Book 1)

It was considered the most comprehensive and factual biography of Pearl Hart available, as she spread a lot of misinformation about herself.

"

For the sake of our story, I will refer to her as Pearl throughout, but she doesn't start using that alias until adulthood.

— Episode: 370 - Necessary Yelling

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 370 - Necessary Yelling

It was considered the most comprehensive and factual biography of Pearl Hart available, as she spread a lot of misinformation about herself.

"

For the sake of our story, I will refer to her as Pearl throughout, but she doesn't start using that alias until adulthood.

the main source used in today's episode is the book Wildcat by John Boasnecker.

This book seems to be the most comprehensive and factual biography of Pearl Hart that's out there because there's a lot of misinformation that she herself spread.

Buffalo is considered, quote, one of the roughest and most dangerous towns in America.

the vast majority of women in the 19th century did not have sexual relations outside of marriage. They did not smoke and they certainly did not use opium and morphine. They did not wear men's clothing, ride a straddle or carry six shooters.

Blood of the Prophets: Brigham Young and the Massacre at Mountain Meadows Cover

Will Bagley

Blood of the Prophets

Brigham Young and the Massacre at Mountain Meadows

It was mentioned as a source for the Mountain Meadows Massacre story, and it was used to question the validity of the rumours that were spread about the Arkansas immigrants.

"

would men with families act so recklessly and provoke people who were known to be intolerant of outsiders.

— Episode: 369 - Blizzard Hotline

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 369 - Blizzard Hotline

It was mentioned as a source for the Mountain Meadows Massacre story, and it was used to question the validity of the rumours that were spread about the Arkansas immigrants.

"

would men with families act so recklessly and provoke people who were known to be intolerant of outsiders.

Massacre at Mountain Meadows Cover

Ronald W. Walker

Massacre at Mountain Meadows

It was cited as a source for the Mountain Meadows Massacre story, detailing the incident and its aftermath, including the church's later apology and the release of previously unseen documents.

"

the conspirators saw just two chilling options. They could lift the siege and let the immigrants carry the word of the attack to California, which they feared would unleash aggression on the Southern...

— Episode: 369 - Blizzard Hotline

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 369 - Blizzard Hotline

It was cited as a source for the Mountain Meadows Massacre story, detailing the incident and its aftermath, including the church's later apology and the release of previously unseen documents.

"

the conspirators saw just two chilling options. They could lift the siege and let the immigrants carry the word of the attack to California, which they feared would unleash aggression on the Southern Mormon settlements, or they could leave no immigrants alive who are old enough to quote tell tales.

Remarkably Bright Creatures: A Novel Cover

Shelby Van Pelt

Remarkably Bright Creatures

A Novel

It was described as a feel-good book with a mystery involving an old lady, an octopus, and the disappearance of her son, ultimately having a positive outcome.

"

Oh, I read a really good book that's like a feel good book. So I wanted to pass that along. Yes. Called Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt.

— Episode: 366 - High-Pitched Goodbye

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 366 - High-Pitched Goodbye

It was described as a feel-good book with a mystery involving an old lady, an octopus, and the disappearance of her son, ultimately having a positive outcome.

"

Oh, I read a really good book that's like a feel good book. So I wanted to pass that along. Yes. Called Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt.

And it's essentially about an old lady, right? Who they live in this small beach town. She is the night cleaner of the town's aquarium. There's an octopus who lives there who's like super smart and remarkably bright creature and they become friends.

But there's also like a mystery. Her son went missing and all this shit. And the octopus knows what happened to her son and has to like figure out a way to octopus tell her.

And it's also like super heart wrenching, but you know, it's going to turn out good in the end. And it totally does. It's like a tear jerker.

That's the last line of that book, right? And that's the day. And then it's a link to the Netflix movie.

Alive in Their Garden: The True Story of the Mirabal Sisters and Their Fight for Freedom Cover

Dedé Mirabal

Alive in Their Garden

The True Story of the Mirabal Sisters and Their Fight for Freedom

It was mentioned as a book about the Mirabal sisters and their work against the Trujillo regime, written by one of the surviving sisters.

"

After her sister's death, Dede Maribol makes it her life's work to keep her sister's memories alive and tell their story. She raises her sister's six children as her own with the help of her mother. I...

— Episode: 366 - High-Pitched Goodbye

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 366 - High-Pitched Goodbye

It was mentioned as a book about the Mirabal sisters and their work against the Trujillo regime, written by one of the surviving sisters.

"

After her sister's death, Dede Maribol makes it her life's work to keep her sister's memories alive and tell their story. She raises her sister's six children as her own with the help of her mother. In addition to raising her own sons, which is amazing, she establishes both the Maribol Sisters Foundation and a museum in honor of her sisters in the early 1990s and writes a book called Alive in Their Garden about them and their work.

In the Time of the Butterflies (Penguin Vitae) Cover

Julia Alvarez

In the Time of the Butterflies (Penguin Vitae)

It was mentioned as a novel about the Mirabal sisters that was later adapted into a film starring Selma Hayek.

"

Other books are written, including the famous novel In the Time of Butterflies by Julia Alvarez, which is later turned into a movie starring Selma Hayek.

— Episode: 366 - High-Pitched Goodbye

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 366 - High-Pitched Goodbye

It was mentioned as a novel about the Mirabal sisters that was later adapted into a film starring Selma Hayek.

"

Other books are written, including the famous novel In the Time of Butterflies by Julia Alvarez, which is later turned into a movie starring Selma Hayek.

Crazy, With the Papers to Prove It Cover

Dan Coughlin

Crazy, With the Papers to Prove It

It was mentioned as a book by a sportswriter about the chaotic 1974 Cleveland Indians 10 cent beer night.

"

a 1974 Associated Press article by the writer Richard Bellotti and the book Crazy with the Papers to Prove It by sports writer Dan Coughlin.

— Episode: 366 - High-Pitched Goodbye

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 366 - High-Pitched Goodbye

It was mentioned as a book by a sportswriter about the chaotic 1974 Cleveland Indians 10 cent beer night.

"

a 1974 Associated Press article by the writer Richard Bellotti and the book Crazy with the Papers to Prove It by sports writer Dan Coughlin.

Great Crimes of San Francisco Cover

Dean W. Dickensheet

Great Crimes of San Francisco

It was mentioned as a source for the story of Theodore Durrant, the 'Demon of the Belfry', which is featured in one of the essays. The book's cover art was described as being aesthetically beautiful in the 70s style.

"

On a recent trip to Green Apple Books, fourth generation SF native here, I found the following.

— Episode: 365 - You Don't Ever Know

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 365 - You Don't Ever Know

It was mentioned as a source for the story of Theodore Durrant, the 'Demon of the Belfry', which is featured in one of the essays. The book's cover art was described as being aesthetically beautiful in the 70s style.

"

On a recent trip to Green Apple Books, fourth generation SF native here, I found the following.

It's a collection of essays and almost all of the cases were unknown to me.

The one that stopped me in my tracks, and which I think would be an excellent tale for MFM, is that of Theodore Durant, also known as the Demon in the Belfry.

His tone is very dry and matter-of-fact, considering how horrifying the subject is.

And the rest of the sources are in our show notes if you want to read up on anything.

Ma Barker: America's Most Wanted Mother Cover

Chris Enss

Ma Barker

America's Most Wanted Mother

It was used as a primary source for the podcast episode's segment on Ma Barker, which focused on her life, the Barker-Karpis gang, and the FBI's role in taking them down.

"

the James boys were raised like Jesse James family, were raised by strong defiant mothers who made sure that they knew how to use a weapon and fight for what they wanted.

— Episode: 364 - The B-I

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 364 - The B-I

It was used as a primary source for the podcast episode's segment on Ma Barker, which focused on her life, the Barker-Karpis gang, and the FBI's role in taking them down.

"

the James boys were raised like Jesse James family, were raised by strong defiant mothers who made sure that they knew how to use a weapon and fight for what they wanted.

Public Enemies: America's Criminal Past, 1919-1940 Cover

William J. Helmer

Public Enemies

America's Criminal Past, 1919-1940

It was discussed as another key source of information for the Ma Barker segment of the episode, exploring the context of public enemy figures during the Great Depression.

"

Americans in the depression found something to admire in the bold and desperate men who only stole from the banks what the banks stole from the people.

— Episode: 364 - The B-I

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 364 - The B-I

It was discussed as another key source of information for the Ma Barker segment of the episode, exploring the context of public enemy figures during the Great Depression.

"

Americans in the depression found something to admire in the bold and desperate men who only stole from the banks what the banks stole from the people.

If Americans found something almost romantic in Bonnie and Clyde, a boy and girl bandit team, despite their murderous ways, the notion of a mother and son bandit team also appealed to the country's streak of rebellion against authority, especially when most police of the day were regarded as only a cut above the crooks they were supposed to catch.

The Demonologist: The Extraordinary Career of Ed and Lorraine Warren Cover

Gerald Brittle

The Demonologist

The Extraordinary Career of Ed and Lorraine Warren

It was given to the email sender by Lorraine Warren after a birthday dinner with her, where she also shared her phone number and some paranormal stories.

"

And as she was signing it to me, she said, I'm also going to write my phone number in here because you're going to need help one day.

— Episode: MFM Minisode 316

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: MFM Minisode 316

It was given to the email sender by Lorraine Warren after a birthday dinner with her, where she also shared her phone number and some paranormal stories.

"

And as she was signing it to me, she said, I'm also going to write my phone number in here because you're going to need help one day.

The Life and Afterlife of Harry Houdini Cover

Joe Posnanski

The Life and Afterlife of Harry Houdini

The book explored the possibility that branches of spiritualism were tied to organized crime and that Houdini's death could have been the result of poisoning by criminal groups.

"

There are two actually Houdini biographers, William Kalish and Larry Sloman, who think those gut punches and appendicitis stories are all red herrings. They wrote a book a few years ago, suggesting th...

— Episode: 363 - Landed In Marshmallows

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 363 - Landed In Marshmallows

The book explored the possibility that branches of spiritualism were tied to organized crime and that Houdini's death could have been the result of poisoning by criminal groups.

"

There are two actually Houdini biographers, William Kalish and Larry Sloman, who think those gut punches and appendicitis stories are all red herrings. They wrote a book a few years ago, suggesting that certain branches of spiritualism had ties to organized crime.

If You Tell: A True Story of Murder, Family Secrets, and the Unbreakable Bond of Sisterhood Cover

Gregg Olsen

If You Tell

A True Story of Murder, Family Secrets, and the Unbreakable Bond of Sisterhood

It was described as a compelling and fast-paced read, offering the most comprehensive account of the Notech family's story, particularly highlighting the abuse Shelly inflicted on her daughters and others.

"

I just read If You Tell by Greg Olson and it was insane.

— Episode: 358 - A Socially Awkward Person's Great...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 358 - A Socially Awkward Person's Great Idea

It was described as a compelling and fast-paced read, offering the most comprehensive account of the Notech family's story, particularly highlighting the abuse Shelly inflicted on her daughters and others.

"

I just read If You Tell by Greg Olson and it was insane.

So if you're interested in this case, you should definitely read If You Tell by Greg Olson.

It's a very compelling read. It goes really fast and it is the most comprehensive writing that you can find on this case.

he's described as, quote, quick-witted and could pour on the charm. He's a smooth talker and a master of BS.

the reason why my mom was able to control Dave was because while I love him, he's just a very weak man. He has no backbone.

The Making of Us: A Novel Cover

Lisa Jewell

The Making of Us

A Novel

It was described as a light mystery about four siblings who discover they share a sperm donor, and involves a murder or possible murder.

"

I read a really good book called The Making of Us by Lisa Jewell.

— Episode: 354 - Heist You Up

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 354 - Heist You Up

It was described as a light mystery about four siblings who discover they share a sperm donor, and involves a murder or possible murder.

"

I read a really good book called The Making of Us by Lisa Jewell.

And it's basically one of those stories of a sperm donor and the four siblings who find each other as adults that were children of the sperm donor, but there's a mystery and there's some murder going on in it.

Or possible murder. I don't want to spoil it. But it was really... It's good.

It's like a mystery, but not too heavy.

A light hearted, a light mystery.

Anxiety Rx: A Revolutionary New Prescription for Anxiety Relief―from the Doctor Who Created It Cover

Russell Kennedy

Anxiety Rx

A Revolutionary New Prescription for Anxiety Relief―from the Doctor Who Created It

It was described as a great book that offered a new perspective on anxiety, viewing it as an alarm system within the body, and was highly recommended for those wanting to better understand and manage their anxiety.

"

It's called Anxiety Rx and it's by this doctor named Russell Kennedy who created this like new way.

— Episode: 352 - Serve The Children

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 352 - Serve The Children

It was described as a great book that offered a new perspective on anxiety, viewing it as an alarm system within the body, and was highly recommended for those wanting to better understand and manage their anxiety.

"

It's called Anxiety Rx and it's by this doctor named Russell Kennedy who created this like new way.

He has anxiety. He's had it his whole life. And he, I don't know, he's just giving me this new way to look at my own anxiety and to look at what anxiety is and how it's more this alarm in the body and that our brain picks up on and just runs with.

I don't know. It's just a really great book and I highly recommend it for people who want to understand their anxiety a little more and in that way are able to help themselves.

Anxiety Rx by Russell Kennedy, MD.

Note: The book recommendations on this page are discovered automatically from podcast transcripts, and may be incorrect or incomplete.