My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Book Recommendations

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners.  Since MFM launched in January of 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest...

Episodes 1,279
Books 770

Recently mentioned

Latest Recommendations

Apples to Oregon: Being the (Slightly) True Narrative of How a Brave Pioneer Father Brought Apples, Peaches, Pears, Plums, Grapes, and Cherries (and Children) Across the Plains (Anne Schwartz Books) cover

Apples to Oregon

Deborah Hopkinson

Mentioned 1 month ago

534 - Think About the Simulation

They introduced the book as a children's story about a 1800s Midwestern pioneer family traveling west, loosely inspired by Johnny Appleseed.

If you were a kid in the 90s, and in elementary school, a teacher read you a book about a family of pioneers. ... It's called Apples to Oregon by a writer named Deborah Hopkinson, and it follows an 1800s Midwestern family in their westward journey.

Buy on Amazon
Survivor of the Killing Fields cover

Survivor of the Killing Fields

Haing S. Ngor

Mentioned 1 month ago

534 - Think About the Simulation

They noted that a book titled The Killing Fields had been written and served as the source material for the film about the Cambodian genocide.

They had written the book, The Killing Fields.

Buy on Amazon
Death in the City of Light: The Serial Killer of Nazi-Occupied Paris cover

Death in the City of Light

David King

Mentioned 1 month ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 98: Grasp It

The hosts noted that the book covered the dark, twisted tale of Marcel Petiot, providing location maps of Paris and details of his meetings, victims, and trial.

I came across a book in my local library called Death in the City of Light, the serial killer of Nazioccupied Paris. What a dark, twisted tale and man. The book provided location maps in Paris, including the house that neighbors reported burning, which led to Petrois being found out and arrested. The book also covers his meetings with specific victims and how he manipulated them to come to his home in the first place. It also covers the trial of Petrois, which was one of the most frustrating reads I've ever had to get through.

Buy on Amazon
Drawn to Injustice: The Wrongful Conviction of Timothy Masters cover

Drawn to Injustice

Timothy Masters

Mentioned 1 month ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 98: Grasp It

The episode mentioned that Timothy Masters authored a book recounting his experience of being tried, imprisoned, and ultimately exonerated for Peggy Hetrick's murder.

Timothy Masters wrote a book detailing his experience being tried, jailed, and exonerated for Peggy's murder titled Drawn to Injustice, the Wrongful Conviction of Timothy Masters.

Buy on Amazon
The Woman They Could Not Silence: One Woman, Her Incredible Fight for Freedom, and the Men Who Tried to Make Her Disappear (True Story of the Historical Battle for Women's and Mental Health Rights) cover

The Woman They Could Not Silence

Kate Moore

Mentioned 2 months ago

533 - An Exercise in Frustration

The hosts highlighted Kate Moore's 2021 book, noting it revived interest in Elizabeth Packard's story and contributed to recent mentalhealth awareness.

Here's Kate Moore's book, she's an amazing author, oh yeah the one they could not silence, very cool.

Buy on Amazon
The Flowers in the Attic Saga (Boxed Set): Flowers in the Attic/Petals on the Wind; If There Be Thorns/Seeds of Yesterday; Garden of Shadows (Dollanganger) cover

The Flowers in the Attic Saga (Boxed Set)

V.C. Andrews

Mentioned 2 months ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 97: The Hague

They referred to *Flowers in the Attic* as a V.C.Andrews book, calling it problematic and discussing its controversial content.

there's a V.C. Andrews book. Flowers in the Attic? No. It's a problematic book that they talked about and they said it was controversial.

Buy on Amazon
When a Killer Calls: A Haunting Story of Murder, Criminal Profiling, and Justice in a Small Town (Cases of the FBI's Original Mindhunter, 2) cover

When a Killer Calls

John E. Douglas

Mentioned 2 months ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 97: The Hague

They mentioned that there is a book called *Mindhunter* which the case or show was based on.

there is a book called Mindhunter and that's what it's based on.

Buy on Amazon
ShadowMan: An Elusive Psycho Killer and the Birth of FBI Profiling cover

ShadowMan

Ron Franscell

Mentioned 2 months ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 97: The Hague

The hosts said Ron Franshell had written the book *ShadowMan* about the case and the birth of FBI profiling, noting it sounded interesting to check out.

there are no case updates, but in January of 2022, journalist and author Ron Franshell wrote the book Shadow Man, an elusive psycho killer and the birth of FBI profiling about this case and the role it played in the FBI's first criminal profile, which I think is so interesting. We should all check that out.

Buy on Amazon
Nancy Drew Starter Set - Books 1-5 cover

Nancy Drew Starter Set - Books 1-5

Carolyn Keene

Mentioned 2 months ago

532 - We’re Being Artists Here

The hosts explained that the original 1930s Nancy Drew novel entered the public domain and they had annotated it for a $10 purchase.

Nancy Drew went public domain in January, and nobody is talking about what that actually means. The version of Nancy Drew that most of us grew up with, the 1959 version, is not the original version. As of January 2026, that original text is free. It's public domain. So I annotated it. The link is in my bio. Wow. It's $10.

Buy on Amazon
Shakespeare Comes to Broadmoor: The Actors are Come Hither' - The Performance of Tragedy in a Secure Psychiatric Hospital cover

Shakespeare Comes to Broadmoor

Murray Cox

Mentioned 2 months ago

532 - We’re Being Artists Here

They noted that the primary source for the episode was the book Shakespeare Comes to Broadmoor compiled by Dr. Murray Cox.

The main source for this story is a book called Shakespeare Comes to Broadmoor, which was compiled by the doctor who spearheaded this program, Dr. Murray Cox.

Buy on Amazon
Parts Work: An Illustrated Guide to Your Inner Life cover

Parts Work

Tom Holmes

Mentioned 2 months ago

532 - We’re Being Artists Here

They referred to a book titled Parts Work while discussing therapeutic concepts.

the book's called Parts Work.

Buy on Amazon
The Blind Side: Evolution of a Game cover

The Blind Side

Michael Lewis

Mentioned 2 months ago

Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 96: Live at the Hard Rock in Orlando

A brief reference was made to "The Blind Side" as a comparison while discussing a sensational story.

the blind side

Buy on Amazon

Most Recommended

The Clan of the Cave Bear Cover

Jean M. Auel

The Clan of the Cave Bear

It was mentioned as a book that Georgia Hardstark remembered from when she was younger. It was used as an example of how certain books can imprint in one's memory.

"

That's the one I fucking, that has imprinted on me.

— Episode: 418 - Assume It's A Masterpiece

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 418 - Assume It's A Masterpiece

It was mentioned as a book that Georgia Hardstark remembered from when she was younger. It was used as an example of how certain books can imprint in one's memory.

"

That's the one I fucking, that has imprinted on me.

Secrets of the Congdon Mansion Cover

Joe Kimball

Secrets of the Congdon Mansion

The gift shop at Glensheen Mansion had books about the murders that occurred there, which were briefly discussed on the tour when appropriate and respectful.

"

And we directed people to the books on the topic in the gift shop.

— Episode: MFM Minisode 373

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: MFM Minisode 373

The gift shop at Glensheen Mansion had books about the murders that occurred there, which were briefly discussed on the tour when appropriate and respectful.

"

And we directed people to the books on the topic in the gift shop.

Every Breath You Take Cover

Miranda Rijks

Every Breath You Take

It was mentioned in the context of a murder in Sarasota, Florida, where the victim had requested Ann Rule write her story if anything happened to her. The victim's mother, the email writer's mother, had emailed Ann Rule about the murder.

"

Interestingly, this murder is also referred to on the book jacket of the book Ann did write as the quote, 'first true crime book written at the victim's request because Sheila herself had said that qu...

— Episode: MFM Minisode 371

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: MFM Minisode 371

It was mentioned in the context of a murder in Sarasota, Florida, where the victim had requested Ann Rule write her story if anything happened to her. The victim's mother, the email writer's mother, had emailed Ann Rule about the murder.

"

Interestingly, this murder is also referred to on the book jacket of the book Ann did write as the quote, 'first true crime book written at the victim's request because Sheila herself had said that quote, 'if anything ever happens to me, find Ann Rule and ask her to write my story.'

She says she emailed her to tell her that she had to write a book about this story.

When I asked her about this recently, she was weirdly tight lipped except to say once she called the house looking for me, but I was at the office. So she hung up and called me there. She had a really high pitched voice.

'just got another email from my friend Ann'.

But when I ordered a copy of Every Breath You Take and checked the acknowledgement section, there was my mom's name.

A Woman of No Importance: The Untold Story of the American Spy Who Helped Win World War II Cover

Sonia Purnell

A Woman of No Importance

The Untold Story of the American Spy Who Helped Win World War II

It was mentioned as a book about Virginia Hall, a WWII spy, and the speaker found it to be a good pick with details about her life and experiences.

"

You always love it when a researcher's like, read this book, you'll like it, it's good.

— Episode: 415 - Be A Better You

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 415 - Be A Better You

It was mentioned as a book about Virginia Hall, a WWII spy, and the speaker found it to be a good pick with details about her life and experiences.

"

You always love it when a researcher's like, read this book, you'll like it, it's good.

Oh, hell yeah. When Hannah sent me this one, she was like, holy shit, what happened?

Miracle Creek: A Novel Cover

Angie Kim

Miracle Creek

A Novel

It was described as a murder/death/mystery with explosions, where the reader solves a case through the perspectives of different characters, including a strong, yet flawed female lead.

"

Okay, so this is new to me author named Angie Kim and she wrote a book called Miracle Creek.

— Episode: 414 - Weather Influencers

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 414 - Weather Influencers

It was described as a murder/death/mystery with explosions, where the reader solves a case through the perspectives of different characters, including a strong, yet flawed female lead.

"

Okay, so this is new to me author named Angie Kim and she wrote a book called Miracle Creek.

And then more recently, a book called Happiness Falls and I've read them both.

And oh, they're good.

They're like murder slash death slash, you know, like explosion mystery, not in both, but each of those have those themes that you're trying to solve through the case, through the book.

It's based on like different perspectives from different characters, usually a strong female lead who's totally fallible and it's like what happened. It's not what you think it is. It's like, it's really, it's really smart. It's this smart mystery.

Midwest Center Attacking Anxiety & Depression (18 Audio CDs and Manual) Paperback Cover

Lucinda Bassett

Midwest Center Attacking Anxiety & Depression (18 Audio CDs and Manual) Paperback

Nadine, a neighbor, gifted a book series about managing anxiety and depression, hoping it would be helpful to the listener who was also experiencing similar struggles.

"

She had a big plastic book filled with cassette tapes. Remember that's how audiobooks used to come.

— Episode: MFM Minisode 369

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: MFM Minisode 369

Nadine, a neighbor, gifted a book series about managing anxiety and depression, hoping it would be helpful to the listener who was also experiencing similar struggles.

"

She had a big plastic book filled with cassette tapes. Remember that's how audiobooks used to come.

The cover read, 'Attacking Anxiety and Depression'. She explained that this series helped her tremendously many years ago and wanted to share it with me.

Having and Being Had Cover

Eula Biss

Having and Being Had

It was recommended by someone on Book Talk. It is a powerful look at the ways we assign value to the people, places, and things in our lives. It was described as an interesting essay series that is well-written and compelling.

"

Her name is Eula Bliss, E-U-L-A.

— Episode: 413 - Learned & Forgotten

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 413 - Learned & Forgotten

It was recommended by someone on Book Talk. It is a powerful look at the ways we assign value to the people, places, and things in our lives. It was described as an interesting essay series that is well-written and compelling.

"

Her name is Eula Bliss, E-U-L-A.

Time Magazine writes, a powerful look at the ways in which we assign value to the people, places, and things that comprise our lives.

It's really good writing.

I couldn't stop reading this book and then they held it up to the camera.

It's like a still life of a table with lobster stuff on it.

The Boxcar Children Mysteries Boxed Set 1-4: The Boxcar Children; Surprise Island; The Yellow House; Mystery Ranch Cover

Gertrude Chandler Warner

The Boxcar Children Mysteries Boxed Set 1-4

The Boxcar Children; Surprise Island; The Yellow House; Mystery Ranch

It was mentioned as a popular children's book series with a similar premise to a story about a family living out of a train car, where children take care of themselves and become orphans.

"

That's like the box car children. It's a wonderful popular children's book series where it's almost the exact same thing, orphans, taking care of themselves and living out of a train car.

— Episode: MFM Minisode 365

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: MFM Minisode 365

It was mentioned as a popular children's book series with a similar premise to a story about a family living out of a train car, where children take care of themselves and become orphans.

"

That's like the box car children. It's a wonderful popular children's book series where it's almost the exact same thing, orphans, taking care of themselves and living out of a train car.

When the Stars Go Dark: A Novel Cover

Paula McLain

When the Stars Go Dark

A Novel

It was described as a quick read, a whodunit mystery with a strong female detective lead, and was set during the time of Polly Klaas' kidnapping, mentioning it and other true crimes.

"

It's called When the Stars Go Dark by Paula McClain.

— Episode: 406 - My Husband's Lovely Wife

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 406 - My Husband's Lovely Wife

It was described as a quick read, a whodunit mystery with a strong female detective lead, and was set during the time of Polly Klaas' kidnapping, mentioning it and other true crimes.

"

It's called When the Stars Go Dark by Paula McClain.

Paula McClain is like a great crime writer.

So it's a quickie. I got into it and out of it real fast listening to it.

Boys Enter the House: The Victims of John Wayne Gacy and the Lives They Left Behind Cover

David Nelson

Boys Enter the House

The Victims of John Wayne Gacy and the Lives They Left Behind

It was mentioned as a book written about the victims of John Wayne Gacy and the lives they left behind, and Georgia expressed interest in reading it.

"

Ooh, I want to read that.

— Episode: 405 - Thanks, Smart People

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 405 - Thanks, Smart People

It was mentioned as a book written about the victims of John Wayne Gacy and the lives they left behind, and Georgia expressed interest in reading it.

"

Ooh, I want to read that.

The Surgeon of Crowthorne : A Tale of Murder, Madness and Love of Words Cover

Simon Winchester

The Surgeon of Crowthorne

A Tale of Murder, Madness and Love of Words

It was discussed as a book about William Chester Minor, who contributed greatly to the Oxford English Dictionary while residing in a psychiatric hospital for killing a man.

"

My main source for today is a book that you may have heard of. Originally the book was called 'The Professor and the Madman'. But that is now a title that the author Simon Winchester isn't comfortable...

— Episode: 403 - Thrive & Survive

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 403 - Thrive & Survive

It was discussed as a book about William Chester Minor, who contributed greatly to the Oxford English Dictionary while residing in a psychiatric hospital for killing a man.

"

My main source for today is a book that you may have heard of. Originally the book was called 'The Professor and the Madman'. But that is now a title that the author Simon Winchester isn't comfortable with, because the word madman is antiquated and offensive in regard to mental illness.

So the name of the book is now 'The Surgeon of Crowthorne' by Simon Winchester. But I think most people remember the book, 'The Professor and the Madman'. It's a good book. Anyways, that's all to say that.

And again, that book that you should read is called 'The Surgeon of Crowthorne' by Simon Winchester.

I'm almost positive it's on my dad's. Yes. Absolutely. And this one was called 'The Professor and the Madman'. So if you see that, steal it from your parents.

The Premonition Poisoner: The True Story Of Serial Killer, Tillie Klimek (True crime murderers) Cover

Charlese Ellis

The Premonition Poisoner

The True Story Of Serial Killer, Tillie Klimek (True crime murderers)

It was mentioned as the main source for the story of Tilly Klimek, a serial killer known as the "Premonition Poisoner."

"

My main source of the story is a book called The Premonition Poisoner, The True Story of Serial Killer Tilly Clemeck by Charlize Ellis.

— Episode: 402 - Staunch Women

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 402 - Staunch Women

It was mentioned as the main source for the story of Tilly Klimek, a serial killer known as the "Premonition Poisoner."

"

My main source of the story is a book called The Premonition Poisoner, The True Story of Serial Killer Tilly Clemeck by Charlize Ellis.

The Five: The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper Cover

Hallie Rubenhold

The Five

The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper

It was described as incredibly good, focusing on the lives of the five canonical victims of Jack the Ripper, excluding any details about the murders themselves.

"

I started reading The Five. Yes. Oh, that book is so goddamn good. By Haley Rubinhold, which is so incredible. It's about the canonical five known victims of Jack the Ripper, and it's...

— Episode: 401 - Keep A Lid On It

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 401 - Keep A Lid On It

It was described as incredibly good, focusing on the lives of the five canonical victims of Jack the Ripper, excluding any details about the murders themselves.

"

I started reading The Five. Yes. Oh, that book is so goddamn good. By Haley Rubinhold, which is so incredible. It's about the canonical five known victims of Jack the Ripper, and it's only about their lives. That's it.

70 Times 7: Daniel's Mysterious Countdown and the Church's Heroic Future Cover

Nelson Walters

70 Times 7

Daniel's Mysterious Countdown and the Church's Heroic Future

It was mentioned as a true crime book by author Alex Marr about one of America's youngest death row inmates.

"

And then on Wicked Words Kate Winkler Dawson talks to true crime author Alex Marr about her book 70 Times 7 which is about one of America's youngest death row inmates so make sure to...

— Episode: 401 - Keep A Lid On It

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 401 - Keep A Lid On It

It was mentioned as a true crime book by author Alex Marr about one of America's youngest death row inmates.

"

And then on Wicked Words Kate Winkler Dawson talks to true crime author Alex Marr about her book 70 Times 7 which is about one of America's youngest death row inmates so make sure to check that out.

The Grape Cure Cover

Johanna Brandt

The Grape Cure

Felix Vail and Sharon Hensley, while in a relationship, became fixated on the book's prescribed grape-only diet and went on journeys across California, sometimes including Felix's young son, Bill.

"

They become mutually obsessed with Felix's current interest, which is a 1928 book called The Grape Cure, which prescribes an all grape diet.

— Episode: 398 - Gloria & Colleen

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 398 - Gloria & Colleen

Felix Vail and Sharon Hensley, while in a relationship, became fixated on the book's prescribed grape-only diet and went on journeys across California, sometimes including Felix's young son, Bill.

"

They become mutually obsessed with Felix's current interest, which is a 1928 book called The Grape Cure, which prescribes an all grape diet.

Cult of the Great Eleven Cover

Samuel Fort

Cult of the Great Eleven

It was the main source of the story of May Otis Blackburn and her daughter, and the basis for the podcast episode, detailing the formation and operation of the cult.

"

It's one book written by a man called Samuel Fort and it's called The Cult of the Great Eleven.

— Episode: 397 - Doers of Knowing

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: 397 - Doers of Knowing

It was the main source of the story of May Otis Blackburn and her daughter, and the basis for the podcast episode, detailing the formation and operation of the cult.

"

It's one book written by a man called Samuel Fort and it's called The Cult of the Great Eleven.

So we do what Samuel Fort does because he truly is the primary source of the story I'm about to tell you. So this is the story of the Cult of the Great Eleven.

as soon as May realized she killed the woman, she jumped into her Lincoln and drove rapidly away.

by circumstance or design, all the cult deaths had occurred a year or more before the start of the police investigation.

If you have a chance, because there's many, many more details and insanity and craziness, you have to read Samuel Fort's The Cult of the Great Eleven because this is a synopsis of that.

Note: The book recommendations on this page are discovered automatically from podcast transcripts, and may be incorrect or incomplete.