Small Town Murder
Book Recommendations

Small Town Murder

Two comedians look at a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. In depth research, horrible tragedy, and the hosts' comedic spin on the whole thing. New episodes every Thursday!!

Episodes 429
Books 70

Recently mentioned

Latest Recommendations

Romeo And Juliet cover

Romeo And Juliet

William Shakespeare

Mentioned 4 months ago

Worse Than Murder - Starkville, Mississippi

The book was mentioned in the context of what a 13-year-old might have learned in school, suggesting a level of expected literary knowledge compared to the severity of the charges they were facing.

I barely fucking read Romeo and Juliet last year in school. I don't know any of that. I just still don't understand it.

Buy on Amazon
The Stranger She Loved: A Mormon Doctor, His Beautiful Wife, and an Almost Perfect Murder cover

The Stranger She Loved

Shanna Hogan

Mentioned 1 year ago

#531 - Dr Serial Killer - Pleasant Grove, Utah

The book provided a very detailed account of Martin McNeil's life and crimes. The audiobook version was noted to be quite long, suggesting a deep dive into the case.

And I'll give you the title of the book later. So it doesn't give away the whole story here.

Buy on Amazon
Shadow on the Mountain cover

Shadow on the Mountain

Margi Preus

Mentioned 1 year ago

#527 - Killing The Princess - Aspen, Colorado

The podcasters cited this book as their source material for the Aspen murder case, detailing the events surrounding the death of Nancy Pfister and the subsequent investigation and trial of those involved.

100 Things to Do in the Nebraska Sandhills Before You Die cover

100 Things to Do in the Nebraska Sandhills Before You Die

Alan J. Bartels

Mentioned 1 year ago

#519 - Show Me Your Belly - Ord, Nebraska

Alan Bartels presented this book at the 150th anniversary of Fort Hartsuff in Ord, Nebraska. The presentation was part of a schedule of events celebrating the fort's history.

100 things to do in the sand hills before you die

Buy on Amazon
Homicide: A Year on the Killing Streets cover

Homicide

David Simon

Mentioned 1 year ago

#518 - Conspiracy Of Fools - Keithville, Louisiana

The podcasters briefly referenced a book by David Simon, "Homicide: A Year on the Killing Streets", while discussing the detectives' behavior during the investigation.

Blind Eye: How the Medical Establishment Let a Doctor Get Away with Murder cover

Blind Eye

James B. Stewart

Mentioned 1 year ago

#517 - Slaughter At Bloody Ranch - Hondo, New Mexico

It was described as a thinly fictionalized version of this case. The book covers the details of the case, including the autopsies.

I found um there there's a book by the way in 2022 that was written uh called Blind Eye by martha burns and it's they call a thinly fictionalized version of the story i don't like that writing when you shot three people in the fucking eye yeah it's yeah blind eye exactly because everybody turned a blind eye to the abuse but she um it's it's it's it's the case i mean jesus they might have changed a name or two but i mean he just she describes the autopsies like they exactly like they happen so i mean nothing fictional about there i did find cody yeah um yeah he's going under his real name um appears to live in texas at this point he was working in the tire industry for a long time all different tire shops now it looks like he got back into ranch work uh here uh he did go to college as well central mexico new mexico community college and um yep well the one even has listed as where he was jail was in there on it so i was like oh that's got to be him so um yeah there he is there's cody he's out there and um i don't know this is one of those cases where you go fuck what do you do discuss discuss it amongst yourselves because those are the facts i don't know how to judge it because there's so many different emotions coming into it i don't know if his dad forced him to sleep with that woman but if he did that's fucked up too uh that's sick the poor i feel bad for if that happened the only person i feel bad for is that daughter that's it just the daughter yeah me too i feel terrible for her jake seems to be robbed too and he's very sweet about it but yeah that poor guy man yeah i think he he realized it was collateral damage i think and it's just really sad though so if you enjoyed that story or at least how we told it because there's no way to enjoy a story of beatings molestation and murders but you can enjoy how we told it and if you do like that give us five stars on rap you're listening on just say something nice it doesn't matter what you want to say tell us what your favorite let's say you like peanut butter and jelly what kind of jelly do you like is it jam is it regular strawberry grape boysenberry what do you fucking like tell us who's your favorite ninja of the three we want to know either one so do that check us out at shut up and give me murder.com where you get your tickets for live shows september 20th state theater minneapolis come be a part of the biggest small town murder show ever and let's hear the loudest shut up and give me murder of all time we can't wait and then get your tickets for the rest of the year too shut up and give me murder.com follow us on social media at small town murder on instagram at small town pod on facebook and at murder small on twitter patreon.com crime and sports is where you get all the bonus materials and also listen to our other shows crime and sports and your stupid opinions bonus materials five dollars or above gets you everything back catalog a hundreds of episodes and new ones every other week one crime and sports one small town murder and you get access to it all or you can have one cup of coffee come on what do you want here so do that what are you gonna do so follow us do all of that and patreon this week what we have for crime and sports which you have access to the duke lacrosse scandal yeah there's strippers there's allegations and there's a lot of lions so we'll talk all about that then for small town murders we're going to talk about the whole idaho coburger disaster this fucking guy i don't like this guy and i want to talk about him basically i want to call him a schmuck even though it hasn't been it hasn't been done yet you can't be you can't have that much dna and act that pompous about it i'm sorry that's crazy that's fucking crazy yeah so we'll talk all about that shut up and give me murder.com and you get a shout out those happen right fucking now give me the list of the names of the people who would never ever ever force us to have sex with our stepmothers hit me with them right now this week executive producers are cindy ryan happy birthday by the way skyla powell happy birthday holy shit the two years hope they're great days gary howard and dave weasel dave weasel and gary too has been listening a long time but dave weasel is a uh a comedian he's been listening to us for a very long time also he's a wonderful person i've known him from twitter for eight years ago or so he's terrific thank you dave fucking hey there's a salute uh other producers this week are crystal bobsene kelly from oh oh uh hello kelly from the it guys wife oh all right trying to figure out why i wrote that like that that's a hmm i don't know maybe i'm trying to figure out why i want yeah why why did you do that register that everybody not not trying to figure out why they wrote this i'm figuring out why i wrote this like this just make sure you registered that please i think the it guy's wife is jealous and kelly and wants her to leave him alone i don't know maybe she's coming over the house all the time really making wild accusations kelly work for other producers continuing our janice hill scarlet horror beast the third poly T sarah oh it's keen uh jacklyn rose scott big build up very easy i get suspense scottish mcmuffin uh dylan langley on your dark star clay with no last name michael with no last name amanda stewart uh jacob wise tim bland tammy with no last name greg with no last name shadow thomas rebecca kuhnlay cunely uh cunel anna walter walter rank holy shit melissa fees mckenzie malloy uh britney messer derrick lemons almost called him lamont jess dixon maria cc uh sarah ervin william cammer i think joseph g heather b soul like this like the son jim spanish soul sol yeah heather be the from the real world first season i don't think that i don't think that maybe from the boogie i hope not bdp in the fucking house audreanna justice craig craig g uh jen thomas frankie g samantha danino frank grill ashley rose jennifer loya brett brian kush flower child bmx good flower there big smoker big bike rider that's brian i like it i know a lot of things about brian right now good dude yeah he's doing good stuff corny latheam the hey elliot podcast matt with no last name eric sautel lisa hambley annaleigh olson roxanne hinds diana with no last name ml t chrissey with no last name colt cochran the mexicution what is he mexican and kills or does he kill that evidently that is a fantastic name nate sheehan gary jenkins jesse wright sarah cunningham julie d brent howard kathy gonzal goneser uh derek long sherry green amy brooks yasinia marie dump truck all right that's very nice sylvan somebody with a giant round ass uh sylvan deball i think megan murphy just meg murphy uh christy busby oh that would just remind me of busby from australia yeah mark holy shit sherry stanton just sorry not to distract from you christy you're wonderful take anything away from you you're the real hero this week mark busby didn't do shit remember mark busby what a guy he did nothing for us this week you did jesse rimland that's a great land uh megan with no last name cindy with no last name lindsey hood ginger gal alexandria weltalca uh candice pachow reina m uh rihanna maybe uh tiffany herbert nebby knows randy with no last name laurel manion nate brooks scott fineout uh emma emma downing clover with no last name elf with no last name jason hart michelle carmen uh john solomon loyal turkey peter newell newell uh angela jones mother motherfucker jones all right motherfucker sheila van nort emily uh westrick sarah hill jess herring uh reidle reedy re what is that what is that it is why did i write this how did i write this who would do that mark would know last name saraya henry katherine lanino leet lieno uh david holloway angel giovanni andy gilbert mike davis cortney harris victoria barra fernandez barra uh cortney vasquez rj rj callens jr uh dustin brown hip young johnny oh tommy tommy guns hip young tommy guns he may be a boxer we don't know uh brian dubec probably not katey carly carly murkert margaret uh salah salah nayazi salah nayazi uh jalen robertson chavarro with no last name chance mcdaniel hey chance how are you bud uh ray dog jenny uh holche uh christy denler lusco lusco melanie simone diane from spokane carrie turner oh that that rhymes it does that's very cool yeah move to a city that rhymes with your name wissman from i'm jimmy from kisimi nice to meet you that's what you gotta be much better yeah it's gonna be the first name i guess right yeah where the fuck am i carrie turner hayley fisher susan rebout uh melanie de santos alex richmond terra rodriguez joe fenton billy colley matt and jesse schlichten yep the uh d goobelman uh woody woodman zee woodman z what is that that's a road somewhere right uh yeah it wasn't a place somewhere it's a town it's a city yeah i think you're right uh jen holders jen stacy henry nelly noble tracy pettit uh jen fred cameron grip jimmy with no last name melissa with no last name shelly with no last name mason gordon uh libby alder alderfer uh christina and then christina brits i got a feeling that's one person two different patrons thank you well thank you thank you otherwise thank both of you uh jason the no hooker killing trucker james he kills no hookers that's good he kills everybody but hookers christopher sharp you gotta have standards and you know not even standards you gotta have uh just you gotta have an appetite okay otherwise you're not worth it know your appetites that's all georgia uh silent storm kyler with no last name leah works delgado and all of our patrons obviously you guys are the best thank you thank you so much everybody we cannot thank you enough for all that you do for us for all that you continue to do for us tell your friends spread the word keep hanging out with us you want to follow us on social media shut up and give me murder dot com has the drop down menu and until next week everybody it's been our pleasure bye if you like small town murder you can listen early and ad free now by joining wonder e plus in the wonder e app or on apple podcasts prime members can listen early and ad free on amazon music before you go tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at wonder e dot com slash survey

Buy on Amazon
Death Traps: The Survival of an American Armored Division in World War II cover

Death Traps

Belton Cooper

Mentioned 1 year ago

#511 - A Deadly Love - Rutledge, Georgia

The book "Death Trap" by M. William Phillips was referenced as a source for information about the case, particularly providing details about the town of Rutledge, Georgia.

The town is located approximately halfway between Atlanta and Augusta. They call it a blip on a GPS screen. It's a forgotten place, essentially there to serve its people.

Buy on Amazon
Happily Never After cover

Happily Never After

Lynn Painter

Mentioned 2 years ago

#504 - Cold Blooded Obsession - Maricopa, Arizona

The podcast mentions that the woman in question, Nancy, was a romance mystery writer and that there are murders in all of her books.

She was a romance mystery writer who happens to be married to a chef.

Buy on Amazon
Chaos: Charles Manson, the CIA and the Secret History of the Sixties cover

Chaos

Tom O’Neill

Mentioned 2 years ago

#500 - Episode 500!! Slaughter At The Shack - Citronelle, Alabama

The podcast host was checking out this true crime audiobook, called "Chaos" by Tom O'Neill.

I'll tell you one that I am checking out, the true crime one. It's very interesting. It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill.

Buy on Amazon
Wild Game: My Mother, Her Lover, and Me cover

Wild Game

Adrienne Brodeur

Mentioned 2 years ago

#499 - Hermit Horrors - Denio, Nevada

A fictionalized account of the events of this episode was written by Frank Burgeon in a book called Wild Game, published in 1995.

A guy named Frank Burgeon or Bergan wrote a book called Wild Game in 1995 and it's a quote fictionalized account of this exact,

Buy on Amazon
None of This Is True: A Novel cover

None of This Is True

Lisa Jewell

Mentioned 2 years ago

#497 - The Serial Killing Nerd - Bridgeport, Pennsylvania

It was strongly recommended for being a shocking psychological thriller.

If you're in the mood for a shocking psychological thriller, check out None of This is True by Lisa Jewel.

Buy on Amazon
No Regrets: A Fable About Living Your 4th Quarter Intentionally cover

No Regrets

Allen Hunt

Mentioned 2 years ago

#495 - Turning A Husband Into Flowers - Lopez Island, Washington

The podcast mentioned Ann Rule's book, "No Regrets and Other True Crime Cases", which contains a variety of true crime stories, including the story of Ruth Neslund, the subject of the podcast episode.

This was Ann Rule's book is called No Regrets and Other True Crime Cases. It's got a bunch of different stories in it. It was also an A&E city confidential.

Buy on Amazon

Most Recommended

Homicide: A Year on the Killing Streets Cover

David Simon

Homicide

A Year on the Killing Streets

The hosts, especially James Pietragallo, repeatedly cited the book as a benchmark for understanding homicide investigations, noting its detailed accounts of detective diligence, case prioritization, and the complexities of arson and interrogation. They used it to illustrate how real‑world police work compares to the scenarios discussed in each episode, highlighting its relevance to the podcast's focus on murder cases. Overall, the book was portrayed as a valuable reference that deepened their analysis of crime scene evidence and investigative strategies.

Highly Recommended
Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #76 - Don't Wear Overalls To Court in Cincinnati,...

The book was mentioned as an example of a detective who spent hours analyzing a crime scene, specifically the placement of a lady's slippers, before concluding it was a suicide.

"

Like in the David Simon Homicide book, there's this guy, a detective, and he's talking about he spent like six hours in a crime scene, but made all the medical guys wait and everything because something wasn't right about this lady hung herself and something wasn't right about the placement of the slippers.

And he spent like six hours figuring out why it was like that before he could go, OK, it's a suicide.

And before he felt OK about it because he had to figure out, OK, she took her slipper off with one foot and then wrapped the other one.

Well, that's how it fall. But he had to like figure it out.

Episode: #71 - An Extra Terrible Person in Kittery, Maine

The podcast host references David Simon's book "The Homicide", which focuses on Baltimore crime in 1988, and compares the events of the episode to the book's timeline, given the episode takes place in 1987.

"

That's basically the David Simon Homicide book. That takes place in 1988. Wow.

Like I hate to say this, but some of the stuff that happens here, I really wish would have happened a year later because I would have already known about it before when I read about it.

So this is this is fucking amazing. Like I hate to say this, but some of the stuff that happens here, I really wish would have happened a year later because I would have already known about it before when I read about it.

They actually talk about how they had they actually had a murder of somebody at the Inner Harbor and basically it came down from on high that this shit would be solved yesterday. Everyone will get convicted and this will never fucking happen again. And they found that motherfucker that day and around him in the heart and drowned him in the harbor.

They actually talk about that. They actually talk about how they had they actually had a murder of somebody at the Inner Harbor and basically it came down from on high that this shit would be solved yesterday. Everyone will get convicted and this will never fucking happen again. And they found that motherfucker that day and around him in the heart and drowned him in the harbor. Absolutely.

Episode: #61 - The Mannequin Murders in Elkridge, Maryland

The book, written by David Simon, the creator of the Wire, talks about how the Baltimore police department handled high-profile cases and how they prioritized the cases that were considered 'red balls'.

"

they talk about when they have, in the city at least in Baltimore, they call it a red ball. That is a case that is highly attentive. There are people know about it. The fucking, it's on the mayor's radar. He's saying I want that case solved.

And that's all hands on deck. And every day the mayor asks. Oh no, not just ask. Every day you have to have reports that then go to Europe's superiors who then write reports on that. It goes up the chain. The chief wants to be kept involved.

And that's a completely different thing than just like a drug dealer in an alley. You know what I mean? That's just like, if you find it, you find it. If not, if not. If it's an old lady who everybody loves, we're finding this fucker yesterday.

So that's a big deal. So even a year later, they still have a full time detective on all this, which is insane because in the Homicide book, they talk about an 11 year old girl who was sexually assaulted and killed and left in an alley.

And that was a big red ball. But six months later, three months later, the detective, the lead detective was going back in the rotation on other shit. That wasn't the priority anymore. Like the red ball turns yellow. They'd go back to it after a while.

Episode: #29 - A Grinch Of A Killer in Santa Claus, Georgia

It was mentioned in relation to the idea that killers often sleep soundly after committing crimes, whereas innocent people struggle to rest.

"

They talk about that a lot. That's an actual thing. It's becoming clich now, but they actually will put a suspect in the room and let him sit there.

They like to let him stew anyway and get them, you know, get them, let them get scared, let them get worked up.

But they want to see what they do. Yeah, because if he goes to sleep, that's your guy.

They all say that because a man who's caught goes to sleep because they're like, I'm caught. They go to sleep. Now I can rest.

Episode: #23 - A Nasty Pair Of Murders in Ocean Grove, New...

It was mentioned in relation to police interrogation techniques, particularly the importance of not keeping a suspect for extended periods without breaks.

"

I always talk about the David Simon Homicide life on the street.

Episode: #10 - A British Tourist Murdered in Monticello, Fl...

It was mentioned as a book that Baltimore homicide detectives would listen to while on the job, specifically the 'Shaft' soundtrack in the book.

"

They used to do this back in Baltimore. The Homicide book they talk about they would drive down the street to whatever the detectives with the shaft soundtrack.

Episode: #8 - A Trail Of Ashes & Bodies in Otisco, New York

It was mentioned in relation to the difficulty of proving arson cases, specifically how difficult it is compared to other crimes with more obvious evidence.

"

If you read, I brought this book up before the Homicide. The Year on the Killing Streets by David Simon, who's the guy who made the wire and made Homicide life on the street and all that shit. He wrote a book where he followed the Homicide department of Baltimore in 1988.

The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair That Changed America Cover

Erik Larson

The Devil in the White City

Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair That Changed America

The hosts repeatedly highlighted the book as a non‑fiction account of H.H. Holmes' murders during the 1893 Chicago World's Fair, noting how the chaos of the event helped him evade detection. They described it as a creepy yet compelling story and praised it as a fantastic audio listen, encouraging listeners to check it out. Their enthusiastic remarks indicated strong endorsement of the title.

Highly Recommended
Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #478 - Evil Deeds & Ouija Writings - Baileyton, Te...

The Devil in the White City was discussed as a non-fiction book about HH Holmes and the World's Fair in Chicago and his crimes.

"

It's the story of HH Holmes all around the world's fair in Chicago and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great fantastic fantastic listen.

Episode: #477 - Never Sing Your Confession - Highland Heigh...

It is the story of H.H. Holmes, all around the world, spare in Chicago, and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great.

"

The title I'm listening to right now that I'm having a lot of fun listening to is The Devil in the White City. It's called It's by Eric Larson it's the story of H.H. Holmes all around the world spare in Chicago and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great fantastic fantastic listen.

Episode: #476 - The Missing Psychic Gypsy - Estes Park, Col...

It is a story about HH Holmes and the 1893 World's Fair in Chicago and how he was able to get away with his crimes because there was so much going on at the fair, and it's really creepy and great.

"

The title I'm listening to right now that I'm having a lot of fun listening to is The Devil in the White City. It's called It's by Eric Larson it's the story of HH Holmes all around the world spare in Chicago and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great fantastic fantastic listen.

Episode: #475 - One Too Many Girlfriends - Wilmington, Dela...

It was described as a creepy and great listen, telling the story of HH Holmes during the world's fair in Chicago and how he was able to get away with his crimes.

"

It's called It's by Eric Larson. It's the story of HH Holmes all around the world's fair in Chicago and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great fantastic fantastic listen as an Audible

Episode: #474 - Twin Powered Craziness - Hana, Hawaii

The Devil in the White City is a non-fiction book that tells the story of H.H. Holmes, a serial killer who operated during the 1893 World's Fair in Chicago.

"

The title I'm listening to right now that I'm having a lot of fun listening to is The Devil in the White City. It's called It's by Eric Larson. It's the story of H.H. Holmes all around the world's fair in Chicago and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great fantastic fantastic listen as an Audible member.

Episode: #473 - Flying Vampire Tinder Date - Wilber, Nebras...

It was a story about H.H. Holmes in Chicago and how he was able to get away with so much because of all that was going on in the city. It was described as creepy but great.

"

The title I'm listening to right now that I'm having a lot of fun listening to is The Devil in the White City. It's called It's by Eric Larson. It's the story of H.H. Holmes all around the world, spare in Chicago and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great.

Fantastic fantastic listen as an Audible member you can choose one title a month to keep it. You can have it. It's fantastic including latest bestsellers and new releases.

Episode: #472 - Evil Came To Play - Milledgeville, Georgia

The Devil in the White City is a book that tells the story of HH Holmes in Chicago during the world's fair, highlighting how his crimes went undetected because of the commotion of the event. The podcast host described it as creepy but a great listen.

"

The title I'm listening to right now that I'm having a lot of fun listening to is The Devil in the White City. It's called It's by Eric Larson it's the story of HH Holmes all around the world spare in Chicago and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great fantastic fantastic listen as an audible member you can choose one title a month to keep the entire catalog you can have it it's fantastic including latest best sellers and new releases

It's really creepy and really great fantastic fantastic listen.

Episode: #471 - The Talented Mr Psychopath - Amity, Maine

This book, narrated by James Petrogallo, was an audiobook he was listening to at the time of the podcast recording. It tells the story of H.H. Holmes during the World's Fair in Chicago, focusing on his ability to carry out his plans amidst the chaos. It is described as a creepy and fantastic listen.

"

The title I'm listening to right now that I'm having a lot of fun listening to is The Devil in the White City. It's called...it's by Eric Larson. It's the story of H.H. homes all around the world's fair in Chicago and how he was able to get all this done because there was so much stuff going on and it's really creepy and really great...fantastic fantastic listen.

It's really creepy and really great fantastic fantastic listen as an Audible member you can choose one title a month to keep from the entire catalog. You can have it. It's fantastic including latest bestsellers and new releases.

Chaos: Charles Manson, the CIA and the Secret History of the Sixties Cover

Tom O’Neill

Chaos

Charles Manson, the CIA and the Secret History of the Sixties

The host repeatedly highlighted the book as an intriguing true‑crime audiobook about Charles Manson, noting it was available through Audible. Across several episodes, James mentioned it as a very interesting option to check out for listeners. The overall tone was positive but brief, simply pointing listeners toward the title.

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #500 - Episode 500!! Slaughter At The Shack - Citr...

The podcast host was checking out this true crime audiobook, called "Chaos" by Tom O'Neill.

"

I'll tell you one that I am checking out, the true crime one. It's very interesting. It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill.

Episode: #494 - Gossip & Brain Bashing - Cherryville, North...

This true crime book was mentioned as an interesting option to check out.

"

I'll tell you one that I am checking out. The true crime one. It's very interesting. It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill and if you join as an Audible member, you can choose one title a month to keep from the entire catalog.

Episode: #493 - Burning Your BFF - Horn Lake, Mississippi

It was mentioned as an interesting true crime audiobook available on Audible.

"

I'll tell you one that I am checking out, a true crime one. It's very interesting. It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill.

Episode: #492 - Murder Moves In - Summerville, South Caroli...

It was described as a true crime audiobook and is available for free as part of an Audible membership.

"

It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill and if you join as an Audible member, you can choose one title a month to keep from the entire catalog.

Episode: #490 - Hot Tub Horrors - Hot Springs, Montana

The podcast host was checking out a true crime audiobook called "Chaos" by Tom O'Neill, mentioning that it was very interesting.

"

I'll tell you one that I am checking out, the true crime one. It's very interesting. It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill.

Episode: #488 - Write It In Blood - Price, Utah

It was described as a true crime book about Charles Manson. It was recommended by the host.

"

I'll tell you one that I am checking out, the true crime one. It's very interesting. It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill and if you join as an Audible member, you can choose one title a month to keep from the entire catalog including latest best sellers, new releases, right to you, no charge, it's beautiful.

Episode: #487 - Handsome, Charming & Deadly - Radford, Virg...

It was described as a true crime book about Charles Manson and the Manson Family.

"

I'll tell you one that I'm checking out, the true crime one. It's very interesting. It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill.

Episode: #450 - You Are... Not The Father - Deer Park, Wash...

The podcast host mentioned being interested in a true crime audiobook called Chaos by Tom O'Neill.

"

I'll tell you one that I am checking out, the true crime one. It's very interesting. It's called Chaos by Tom O'Neill.

None of This Is True: A Novel Cover

Lisa Jewell

None of This Is True

A Novel

Across six episodes, the host repeatedly recommended the book as a shocking psychological thriller, noting its gripping narrative and immersive sound design. Listeners were encouraged to try it, with one episode mentioning it was available for free via an Audible membership. The overall consensus was that it delivered intense, suspenseful storytelling.

Highly Recommended
Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #497 - The Serial Killing Nerd - Bridgeport, Penns...

It was strongly recommended for being a shocking psychological thriller.

"

If you're in the mood for a shocking psychological thriller, check out None of This Is True by Lisa Jewel.

Episode: #494 - Gossip & Brain Bashing - Cherryville, North...

This psychological thriller book was recommended for its shocking content and captivating sound design.

"

If you're in the mood for a shocking psychological thriller check out None of This Is True by Lisa Jewel embrace brand new exclusive thrillers from bestselling authors who are guaranteed to keep you gripped.

Episode: #492 - Murder Moves In - Summerville, South Caroli...

This shocking psychological thriller is available for free as part of an Audible membership.

"

If you're in the mood for a shocking psychological thriller, check out None of This Is True by Lisa Jewell.

Episode: #490 - Hot Tub Horrors - Hot Springs, Montana

The host recommended the audiobook "None of This is True" by Lisa Jewel as a shocking psychological thriller. It was mentioned that the book had captivating sound design, eerie soundscapes, and dynamic performances.

"

If you're in the mood for a shocking psychological thriller, check out None of This Is True by Lisa Jewel.

Episode: #488 - Write It In Blood - Price, Utah

It was described as a shocking psychological thriller and recommended by the host.

"

If you're in the mood for a shocking psychological thriller, check out None of This Is True by Lisa Jewel.

Episode: #450 - You Are... Not The Father - Deer Park, Wash...

The podcast host recommended a psychological thriller audiobook called "None of This is True" by Lisa Jewel.

"

If you're in the mood for a shocking psychological thriller, check out None of This Is True by Lisa Jewel.

Happily Never After Cover

Lynn Painter

Happily Never After

The hosts referenced the title while discussing a case involving a romance mystery writer whose novels featured murders, noting that the real-life incident mirrored the book's premise of a chef husband’s death and the writer becoming a suspect. They highlighted the author's background and the thematic overlap, but did not endorse the work, treating it as a narrative comparison.

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #504 - Cold Blooded Obsession - Maricopa, Arizona

The podcast mentions that the woman in question, Nancy, was a romance mystery writer and that there are murders in all of her books.

"

She was a romance mystery writer who happens to be married to a chef.

But this story didn't end with a happily ever after.

When I stepped into the kitchen, I could see that Chef Brophy was on the ground and I heard somebody say, call 911.

As writers, we'd written our share of murder mysteries.

So when suspicion turned to Dan's wife Nancy, we weren't that surprised.

The first person they look at would be the spouse. We understand that's usually the way they do it.

But we began to wonder, had Nancy gotten so wrapped up in her own novels... There are murders in all of the books.

that she was playing them out in real life?

Episode: #442 - The Social Media Loving Cannibal - Joppatow...

The podcast hosts mentioned the book 'Happily Never After' and its connection to a murder mystery. They described the book as having murders in it and that it's a romance mystery.

"

She was a romance mystery writer who happens to be married to a chef.

There are murders in all of the books.

As writers, we'd written our share of murder mysteries.

Episode: #438 - An Officer & Three Maniacs - Biloxi, Missis...

The podcast host compared the case to a romance mystery novel, mentioning that there were murders in all of the books, making it a more relatable theme to the listener.

"

There are murders in all of the books.

Episode: #422 - Dead In A Ditch - Claymont, Delaware

The podcast host referenced 'Happily Never After' as a podcast that features a story about a romance mystery writer who is married to a chef. The story takes a dark turn when the chef is found dead, and suspicion falls on the wife, who writes murder mysteries in her novels.

"

Nancy was a romance mystery writer who happens to be married to a chef, but this story didn't end with a happily ever after.

As writers, we'd written our share of murder mysteries. So when suspicion turned to Dan's wife, Nancy, we weren't that surprised.

But we began to wonder had Nancy gotten so wrapped up in her own novels. There are murders in all of the books.

Follow Happily Never After Dan and Nancy on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.

Episode: #414 - Don't Anger The Princess - Bryant, Arkansas

The podcast episode discussed Nancy's love story, which was compared to a romance mystery novel. It was mentioned that she was a romance mystery writer and was married to a chef. Unfortunately, the story did not end with a happily ever after as it was mentioned that Chef Brophy was found on the ground and someone had to call 911. It was also mentioned that Nancy was a suspect in the murder mystery.

"

Nancy's love story could have been ripped right out of the pages of one of her own novels.

She was a romance mystery writer who happens to be married to a chef.

But this story didn't end with a happily ever after.

When I stepped into the kitchen, I could see that Chef Brophy was on the ground and I heard somebody say, call 911.

As writers, we'd written our share of murder mysteries. So when suspicion turned to Dan's wife Nancy, we weren't that surprised.

Fight Club Cover

Chuck Palahniuk

Fight Club

The book was highlighted as a fun read that outshone its film adaptation, with the host expressing excitement about receiving it and praising its logical, satisfying ending. He repeatedly noted the movie was whiny and inferior, emphasizing the book's superiority. Overall, the discussion conveyed a strong recommendation.

Highly Recommended
Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #29 - A Grinch Of A Killer in Santa Claus, Georgia

It was mentioned as a book received in the mail as a gift, and the speaker was enthusiastic about reading it.

"

I got that in the mail and I can't fucking wait to read.

Episode: #28 - A Messy Murder Plot in Kendrick, Idaho

It was discussed as a book that was more enjoyable than the movie, which was considered whiny. The book's ending was also mentioned as more logical and satisfying.

"

The book is so much better than the movie.

Like the book is real fun. The movie's so whiny.

It's so fucking whiny though, the movie.

The ending in the book actually makes sense.

The ending in the movie you're like, what happened there?

Episode: #28 - A Messy Murder Plot in Kendrick, Idaho

It was described as a funny book with a better ending than the movie adaptation, which was deemed whiny by one of the podcast hosts.

"

The book is so much better than the movie.

Like the book is real fun. The movie's so whiny.

It's so fucking whiny though, the movie.

The ending in the book actually makes sense.

The ending in the movie, you're like, what happened there?

Episode: #28 - A Messy Murder Plot in Kendrick, Idaho

It was described as a much better read than the movie, especially in terms of the ending, which was considered more satisfying in the book.

"

The book is so much better than the movie.

The book is real... The movie's so whiny.

It's so fucking whiny though, the movie. That's the thing.

The ending in the book actually makes sense.

The ending in the movie you're like, what happened there?

Mind Hunter: Inside the FBI's Elite Serial Crime Unit Cover

John E. Douglas

Mind Hunter

Inside the FBI's Elite Serial Crime Unit

The hosts referenced the title as a key example of criminal profiling, noting its insights into sexual crime dynamics, the psychological tactics used by offenders like Richard Speck, and the way crime‑scene photos can reveal a perpetrator’s mindset. James Petrogallo and James Pietragallo both encouraged listeners to read the book for a deeper understanding of these concepts. Their discussion highlighted the book’s practical value for anyone interested in forensic psychology.

Highly Recommended
Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #488 - Write It In Blood - Price, Utah

The book Mindhunter was mentioned as an example of profiling that occurs in sexual crimes, specifically related to pressure and sexual release.

"

if you like read Mindhunter and read like a profiler's do this. It always happened near this. There's always the number one, the pressure thing.

Episode: #47 - Anger, Obsession, Revenge in Sun Valley, Nev...

The podcasters mentioned the Mindhunter book and show, focusing on the interview with Richard Speck, who also had to depersonalize his victims to commit his crimes. They connected this behaviour to Robert McConnell's actions.

"

Like if you listen to Mindhunter with John Douglas, now it's a TV show or now it's a Netflix show. That's really good. But if you, if you look at, if you read the Mindhunter book, they go into the details about the Speck interview and it was a D he had to depersonalize it.

Episode: #33 - A Basement Dwelling Predator in Collegeville...

The book was referenced in the context of criminal profiling, specifically how crime scene photos can be used to understand the criminal's mind.

"

That's what he always calls it. He always says, if you want to find the artist, look at the art.

The Book of John (The Smart Guide to the Bible Series) Cover

Lin Johnson

The Book of John (The Smart Guide to the Bible Series)

The title was referenced as Rocky Lee Barton's favorite book in one episode, and in another episode it was credited with prompting Everett Conant III to turn his life over to Jesus and adopt extreme fasting based on its verses. Both hosts presented the book as a powerful spiritual influence for the individuals involved.

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #69 - Loneliness Is Better Than Murder in Waynesvi...

It was mentioned as Rocky Lee Barton's favourite book.

"

The Bible.

Episode: #53 - Tragedy At The Trailer Park in Wheatland, Wy...

It was said that Everett Conant III had turned his life over to Jesus and had decided to stop eating and drinking because of words from the Book of John. He said that he that cometh to me shall never hunger and he that believeth in me shall on me shall never thirst.

"

he that cometh to me shall never hunger and he that believeth in me shall on me shall never thirst.

The Grapes of Wrath Cover

John Steinbeck

The Grapes of Wrath

In two episodes, a local activist and the hosts compared the town's neighborhoods to the bleak, impoverished setting described in the book, noting its relevance to the area’s desolation and hardship. They highlighted how the novel’s imagery captured the broken, struggling atmosphere of Three Points, using it as a vivid point of reference.

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #62 - When Stupid People Kill... in Three Points,...

A local activist compared some neighborhoods to the setting of "The Grapes of Wrath", which was said to be an accurate description of the desolate and impoverished area.

"

She said some neighborhoods out there are straight out of Steinbeck.

It's a little Steinbeck-y.

Episode: #62 - When Stupid People Kill... in Three Points,...

The town of Three Points was described as having a vibe like something straight out of John Steinbeck's "The Grapes of Wrath", a place filled with broken people and hardship.

"

She said, "Some neighborhoods out there are straight out of Steinbeck." She's like, "It's just a fucking disaster basically."

She's calling literary references. That's unbelievable. That's fucking awesome. Unbelievable.

This isn't from the 1800s. This is now they're talking about. Now it's a good place to hide from an ex-wife that wants fucking alimony. Or the law or civilization. And we'll get to in our story, that's the reason why they're here. Really? Oh, this is great. That's why we're making a point of this now. What a quote.

I think that Steinbeck might have a point. I'm just saying that now. That looks nice. Steinbeck's onto something. Now he moves in, in Three Points.

I think that Steinbeck might have a point. I'm just saying that now. That looks nice. Steinbeck's onto something.

Thinner Cover

Stephen King

Thinner

The hosts referenced the book when noting that its film adaptation was shot in Kittery and partly set in Old Orchard Beach, describing the movie as a crazy one. James Pietragallo highlighted the local filming, while Jimmie Whisman called the movie crazy. They did not delve into the novel’s plot or recommend it, merely mentioning it in passing.

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #71 - An Extra Terrible Person in Kittery, Maine

The podcast host mentions that the 1996 film "Thinner" was filmed in Kittery, Maine. The host says that the movie is based on a Stephen King novel of the same name.

"

1996, the movie Thinner, uh, was based here. It's Fitz filmed in Kittery. I'm sorry. The Stephen King novel is based on that.

I was filmed in Kittery. So if you want to know what Kittery looks like, watch a Thinner and you'll see the movie.

Episode: #13 - Murder Bubbling Under The Surface in Old Orc...

It was mentioned that the movie 'Thinner', based on the Stephen King book of the same name, was a crazy movie, possibly also partly set in Old Orchard Beach, Maine.

"

Really? Yeah. He, that's a crazy movie.

Dreisbach's Handbook of Poisoning: Prevention, Diagnosis and Treatment, Thirteenth Edition Cover

Bev-Lorraine TRUE

Dreisbach's Handbook of Poisoning

Prevention, Diagnosis and Treatment, Thirteenth Edition

The book was discovered by investigators in the pantry of the suspect's former husband, serving as a piece of evidence that suggested she had researched poisoning methods. The host expressed shock at finding such a specialized manual among her belongings, highlighting its relevance to the case. The discussion was limited to its role in the investigation rather than any endorsement of its content.

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #58 - "Serial Killer" Doesn't Even Describe It in...

An investigator found "The Handbook of Poisoning" in the pantry of Kristen's former husband, Glenn, which seemed to confirm the suspicions about her actions.

"

Investigators find a book inside called quote the handbook of poisoning.

Episode: #58 - "Serial Killer" Doesn't Even Describe It in...

The book was found in Kristen Gilbert's belongings after she was arrested. It was discovered in a pantry at Glenn Gilbert's house, who she had been married to and was attempting to poison.

"

Investigators find a book inside called, quote, the Handbook of Poisoning.

Holy shit. She might as well have had a picture of her with an old dying man sticking a needle in and smiling with Mickey Mouse ears on. This is fucking ridiculous. The Handbook of Poisoning? What the fuck?

In Cold Blood (Modern Library 100 Best Nonfiction Books) Cover

Truman Capote

In Cold Blood (Modern Library 100 Best Nonfiction Books)

The podcasters mentioned the book "In Cold Blood" as an example of a serious true crime podcast and compared it to the more humorous style of "Small Town Murder".

"

He chopped her head off slowly. You want to hear it like that? Fine dateline. Go ahead. You can go to the bar, get a crock of it, knock yourself out. But that's not...

— Episode: #44 - A Morning Time Slaughter in Kenton...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #44 - A Morning Time Slaughter in Kenton, Delaware

The podcasters mentioned the book "In Cold Blood" as an example of a serious true crime podcast and compared it to the more humorous style of "Small Town Murder".

"

He chopped her head off slowly. You want to hear it like that? Fine dateline. Go ahead. You can go to the bar, get a crock of it, knock yourself out. But that's not...

Keith Morrison does an amazing job at narrating that horrible shit. Fantastic. But he's not funny. But he's not funny at all. And we're going to do... We're going to horrify you and make you laugh. He's funny for the wrong reasons.

He's funny because his face looks like an old man's nut sack.

But we're going to make you laugh and also we're going to shut up and give you murder here. That's what we'll do. So let's do that here. Let's head on a trip, Jimmy.

And the shotgun from In Cold Blood I don't want that gun.

It: A Novel Cover

Stephen King

It

A Novel

It was mentioned that Stephen King wrote a novel that was partly set in Old Orchard Beach, Maine.

"

One of his novels was actually partly set there. I think It was 'It' was partly set there.

— Episode: #13 - Murder Bubbling Under The Surface...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #13 - Murder Bubbling Under The Surface in Old Orc...

It was mentioned that Stephen King wrote a novel that was partly set in Old Orchard Beach, Maine.

"

One of his novels was actually partly set there. I think It was 'It' was partly set there.

The Complete Book of Black Magic and Witchcraft: Including the rituals of Ceremonial Magic, Exorcism, True Sorcery and Infernal Necromancy Cover

Shadow Books

The Complete Book of Black Magic and Witchcraft

Including the rituals of Ceremonial Magic, Exorcism, True Sorcery and Infernal Necromancy

Brian Simmons was found to have a book titled "Witchcraft" in his home, which the prosecution read excerpts from in court to attempt to connect his interest in Satanism to the murder. The book was deemed admissible evidence as it was in plain view and constituted relevant evidence.

"

They said that the witchcraft book was in plain view and constituted relevant evidence, so they deny that also.

— Episode: #79 - Maybe Satan Did It in Dayton, Neva...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #79 - Maybe Satan Did It in Dayton, Nevada

Brian Simmons was found to have a book titled "Witchcraft" in his home, which the prosecution read excerpts from in court to attempt to connect his interest in Satanism to the murder. The book was deemed admissible evidence as it was in plain view and constituted relevant evidence.

"

They said that the witchcraft book was in plain view and constituted relevant evidence, so they deny that also.

Dan Cummins is a serial killer. I don't know if you know that.

I should leave right now. I'm thankful to have this if you look through my shit and I was the you'd be like oh, he absolutely killed anybody that you fucking think that he killed because all he cares about is murder. It's literally all he has so many reports and this is weird.

The state argues that Mike was not a state of a state agent when he took the phone call from him and incriminating sim statements that Simmons made to his friend were used as evidence without violating his right to counsel because if he was an agent of the state then Simmons would have a right to counsel is what they were saying here.

The court of the witchcraft book Simmons contends the book Witchcraft is the name of the book was illegally seized and should not have been admitted at trial because the book was not listed in the search warrant and neither the plain view doctrine nor the good faith exception applies.

Harry Potter Hardcover Boxed Set: Books 1-7 (Slipcase) Cover

J. K. Rowling

Harry Potter Hardcover Boxed Set

Books 1-7 (Slipcase)

The journal is compared to a Harry Potter book, suggesting its length and possibly a compelling story, but without further details.

"

Have you read Harry Potter? I'm going to give you another read.

— Episode: #55 - The Neighborhood Cannibal in South...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #55 - The Neighborhood Cannibal in South Kingstown...

The journal is compared to a Harry Potter book, suggesting its length and possibly a compelling story, but without further details.

"

Have you read Harry Potter? I'm going to give you another read.

Lord of the Flies (Penguin Drop Caps) Cover

William Golding

Lord of the Flies (Penguin Drop Caps)

The lawyer referenced the book to compare the dystopian youth in the novel to the teenagers involved in the murder.

"

The former book reminded him of the dystopian youth involved in the murder of Grunwald

— Episode: #428 - Weak Motives & Wilderness Gangste...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #428 - Weak Motives & Wilderness Gangsters - Palme...

The lawyer referenced the book to compare the dystopian youth in the novel to the teenagers involved in the murder.

"

The former book reminded him of the dystopian youth involved in the murder of Grunwald

The Iliad Cover

Homer

The Iliad

When the family was getting ready for bed, Kathy would read to her sons from one of the classics, likely classics like the Iliad.

"

I may be maybe like classics like classic literary collections like literature or maybe she means...

— Episode: #461 - Wife Swap Snap - Beach City, Ohio

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #461 - Wife Swap Snap - Beach City, Ohio

When the family was getting ready for bed, Kathy would read to her sons from one of the classics, likely classics like the Iliad.

"

I may be maybe like classics like classic literary collections like literature or maybe she means...

No, she probably I'm she probably means like the fucking Iliad and Homer and all that shit.

Romeo And Juliet Cover

William Shakespeare

Romeo And Juliet

The book was mentioned in the context of what a 13-year-old might have learned in school, suggesting a level of expected literary knowledge compared to the severity of the charges they were facing.

"

I barely fucking read Romeo And Juliet last year in school. I don't know any of that. I just still don't understand it.

— Episode: Worse Than Murder - Starkville, Mississi...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: Worse Than Murder - Starkville, Mississippi

The book was mentioned in the context of what a 13-year-old might have learned in school, suggesting a level of expected literary knowledge compared to the severity of the charges they were facing.

"

I barely fucking read Romeo And Juliet last year in school. I don't know any of that. I just still don't understand it.

Democracy Awakening: Notes on the State of America Cover

Heather Cox Richardson

Democracy Awakening

Notes on the State of America

The podcast host was reading a book with a statistic about airline stewardesses, but he doesn't remember the book's title, only mentioning "The stat."

"

Actually, I read a book, there stat, but it was something like that.

— Episode: #465 - Chainsaws, Torsos & Murder Tacos...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #465 - Chainsaws, Torsos & Murder Tacos - Davenpor...

The podcast host was reading a book with a statistic about airline stewardesses, but he doesn't remember the book's title, only mentioning "The stat."

"

Actually, I read a book, there stat, but it was something like that.

Dr. Seuss's Beginner Book Boxed Set Collection: The Cat in the Hat; One Fish Two Fish Red Fish Blue Fish; Green Eggs and Ham; Hop on Pop; Fox in Socks Cover

Dr. Seuss

Dr. Seuss's Beginner Book Boxed Set Collection

The Cat in the Hat; One Fish Two Fish Red Fish Blue Fish; Green Eggs and Ham; Hop on Pop; Fox in Socks

A British kid on YouTube reads Dr. Seuss books and he has Tourette's.

"

This is an older alcoholic woman who literally just made a scowl and went fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck for an hour and a half on a school bus.

— Episode: #72 - Plans Of Torture in Canistota, Sou...

Listen on Audible 7-day free trial

Episode: #72 - Plans Of Torture in Canistota, South Dakota

A British kid on YouTube reads Dr. Seuss books and he has Tourette's.

"

This is an older alcoholic woman who literally just made a scowl and went fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck for an hour and a half on a school bus.

This was like greatest fucking thing I've ever seen.

Note: The book recommendations on this page are discovered automatically from podcast transcripts, and may be incorrect or incomplete.