Hillbilly Elegy
The book was repeatedly cited as a key source for understanding J.D. Vance’s personal journey from a troubled Appalachian upbringing to political prominence, often highlighted by Megyn Kelly as her favorite interview material and a must‑read for listeners. Hosts and guests such as Donald Trump Jr. and Ron Howard referenced its bestseller status and film adaptation, noting its vivid depiction of poverty, family struggle, and the “boot‑strap” narrative. While some critics on the show questioned Vance’s later rhetoric, the overall discussion praised the memoir’s insight into working‑class America.
Episode: Biased Moderators, Bizarre Rules - Previewing Trum...
The book was mentioned in regards to the author, J.D. Vance's, ability to skillfully and artfully win arguments, particularly against journalists. It was mentioned that he's been through a lot and managed to stay spiritually connected to his family. It was noted that the book was made into a movie directed by Ron Howard. J.D. Vance was highlighted as a potential vice-presidential candidate for Donald Trump.
Ron Howard directed a movie based on his book right, I mean he's changed since then, but he has an ability to live in a lot of different worlds and that's a really really, um, a valuable asset for a vice president, J.D. Vance, um, hopefully he's going to be on the show very soon but I've said to the audience from the day we launched, it was literally one of, if not, the most favorite interview I've ever done, it was while I was NBC, it's one of, one of the few very good things that came out of that year, that year plus when I was there and, um, I encourage you to go back and look at the YouTube of it, it's truly worth your 11 minutes, or however long that the piece was, and I don't say this in a sycophantic way, I don't have a girl crush on J.D. Vance, I love only one man and that's my husband, but J.D. Vance is a beautiful person, that's my biggest takeaway, was this is a beautiful man, he has been through a lot and has overcome and has managed to like stay within his own soul, solid, spiritual, connected to his family, very aware of his own failings and the dangers to him given his upbringing, loves his wife, his family, all of his family's nuclear family and the children he has of course with Usha, and I'm rooting for that guy to succeed, I don't really care if it says vice president or a senator, or just as a human, you just the more you learn about him I think the more you like him.
I think it's 100 true, I, I don't think there's anything that's going to diminish the desire of Democrats, if he wins another term to impeach him, I, I think that that's just, but also I think it's funny that I just said about Steve Bannon talking about how much he loves AOC, if you take that, that Don Jr. quote, and you gave it to somebody, I don't know, 10, 15 years ago and you said, who is the person talking about corporate billionaires and warmongers, you would assume it was Noam Chomsky, you would assume it was somebody on the left, I mean, this is why people like Bannon, and why people like Don Jr., uh kind of, you know, respect people on the populist left because it's become, it's become such an overlap, but somebody like J.D. Vance, who I really strongly disagree with on a lot of issues, the one thing you can't take away from him, if you see him, I've seen him dealing with, there was one recent, uh interview he gave to CNN in which they were thought they were going to dunk on him because what, what happens with journalists, when it comes to MAGA types, is that you always assume because you are right and they are wrong, this is from the perspective of the journalist, that it'll be easy right, because you know they just lie and they make things up, J.D. Vance is no dummy, I mean, he's very very skilled at this and I, it was the first person I saw in kind of MAGA universe, so skillfully and artfully, you can win by, you know, as Steve Bannon says in that clip, having a hammer like Matt Boyle, hammer is usually the tool that they use, that would be Vance's uh great advantage.
Episode: Trump Picks His VP, and Jack Smith's Election Inte...
The author discussed his book in the context of the Republican VP pick, and how the left loved it when it was published but turned on him after he started to change his views.
Look, I was wrong about Donald Trump.
I didn't think he was going to be a good president.
He was a great president.
I think you should, when you, when you're wrong about something, you should change your mind and be honest with people about that fact.
I think he's doing that.
Episode: Why Elites Hate Vance, Biden's True Condition, and...
The book was mentioned in relation to J.D. Vance's personal story and his upbringing in Appalachia. It was noted that he discusses his struggles with poverty and the challenges faced by people in those communities.
It's not that he loathes his mom, but I can speak to this personally. When you've got someone in your family, who's got a rampaging drug addiction, it, it ruins them and it can ruin your relationship and it can ruin your family at least temporarily. And those scars may not fully ever heal. And so it was actually really damn brave for them to put her out there. And J.D. didn't try to say like, we're all good. We're all good. You know, talking about her, there was a reference in a speech that kind of suggested she's here and you know, it's complicated.
He writes this thing, Hillbilly Elegy, right. About, about sort of growing up poor and now the people in, but he, but he blames the people for their circumstance. Look, I grew up in poverty. I remember what it feels like to be hungry. I remember what it feels like not to have enough.
He's one of those people that wants people to pull themselves up by the bootstraps when they don't have boots. So he has made it out of Appalachia, but he is blaming those people in Appalachia for the structural problems that keep them there. And I think that is the most despicable thing about him. He wrote a really interesting and smart book about getting on and didn't recognize that he isn't out of poverty. Well, he is bereft. He's bereft of morality. He has, he is bereft of morality. He's bereft of spine with empathy.
Episode: Character Assassination Attempt on Vance, and Offe...
J.D. Vance was accused of misrepresenting his upbringing and changing his principles on various issues, with his former friend mischaracterising his position on gender affirming care for minors, and smearing his wife, Usha.
And he called them lazy, acting like he understands our culture, and he's one of us. He's not.
He said it was weird that I attacked, and this is in his words, his, quote, origin story. Fictional characters have an origin story. Real people have childhoods. So let me be clear, J.D. Vance ain't from Kentucky. He ain't from Appalachia, and he ain't going to be your vice president.
He just started talking in this divisive, dismissive and cool way about people who are different from him. And that is just not the person that I used to know.
Well, I don't think anyone knows what J.D. or Usha believe because they have literally changed their principles on every imaginable issue.
What I think is reflected in both of their changing of their principles on every single issue is that their core value is amassing money and power, not the integrity and kindness that I think are core values of everyone in the Rust Belt.
Episode: J.D. Vance on Democrats' Anti-Family Policies, Med...
The book, published in 2016, was about the author's experiences growing up in Appalachia and the struggles of the white working class.
J.D. Vance is a phony. He's fake.
He claims to be from Eastern Kentucky, tries to write a book about it to profit off our people, and then he calls us lazy.
He's not.
I have read so many think pieces about your book and seen so many interviews with you. I have the book right here.
But your story, first of all, is fascinating. So the way you went from sort of rust belt country to Yale.
Episode: J.D. Vance on Democrats' Anti-Family Policies, Med...
It was mentioned that J.D. Vance's book, Hillbilly Elegy, was published in 2016 and that he was profiled in 2017. Vance's book was referenced as providing insight into his life and upbringing in Eastern Kentucky.
I've got to play a little bit of this because I'd love to get your reaction. Here he is. J.D. Vance is a phony. He's fake. I mean, he first says that Donald Trump is like Hitler, and now he's acting like he's Lincoln. I mean, the problem with J.D. Vance is he has no conviction, but I guess his running mate has 34. He claims to be from Eastern Kentucky, tries to write a book about it to profit off our people, and then he calls us lazy. And this makes me angry, but it especially makes me angry about our people in Eastern Kentucky. Listen, these are the hardworking coal miners that powered the industrial revolution, that helped build the strongest middle class the world has ever seen, helped us win two world wars, and he called them lazy, acting like he understands our culture, and he's one of us. He's not.
He claims to be from Eastern Kentucky, tries to write a book about it to profit off our people, and then he calls us lazy.
And he called them lazy, acting like he understands our culture, and he's one of us. He's not.
And then you move on to Yale Law School and there's Amy Chua, our mutual friend who we love, who encouraged you to write the book and change your life and saw in you this special story in person that ultimately would lead you to enter the national conversation.
And I think even Joy Reid could see it back then. Now, maybe not.
Episode: J.D. Vance on Trump, Addiction, and Family | Novem...
The book was discussed multiple times. It was mentioned as a source for understanding people in the middle of the country. It was also discussed in relation to the perceived hypocrisy of people who did not accept Trump's victory in 2016 but were quick to demand Trump accept the results of the 2020 election. It was mentioned as a source for the code to follow when one feels they have been wronged: to fight. A scene from the book was also discussed in which the author's mom loses her temper in a car and threatens to crash it.
You know, we're going to go read Hillbilly Elegy or some other book to try to understand people in the middle of the country.
Hillbilly Elegy tells us the code to follow when one feels that one has been wronged and that code is to fight, to fight.
I'm not one of these people who says that poor folks don't have any disadvantages. Like, I can't possibly look at my grandma's life and my grandma's upbringing and say she had the same set of opportunities as someone who was born in an upper class background in the 1940s in New York City.
Hillbilly Elegy takes a hard look at sort of the malaise happening in these communities in the Rust Belt, the almost the lack of agency a lot of a lot of these workers have.
There's a line in the book that says hillbillies could go from zero to murderous in a fucking heartbeat.
Episode: J.D. Vance Takes Centerstage, and "Ear Truthers" i...
J.D. Vance's book, Hillbilly Elegy, was mentioned in relation to his remarkable life story and the difficult childhood he had growing up in Appalachia. It was noted that the book provides a deeper understanding of Vance's story than a half-hour speech could.
We talked to you about Beverly earlier in the week when we went back over my long-form interview with him and talked about Hillbilly Elegy.
And I was like, like, that's a guy we need to run for office. Right. You know, it's not the sort of the typical checkbox thing like, yeah, he went to Yale Law, but he went to the Marine Corps out of high school.
And then sort of coming around and come around. It sort of met a while ago now towards, I guess, the end of my father's term, talking a lot, hanging out, became like really good friends with him.
I read Hillbilly Elegy when it came out.
Episode: Trump's Compelling VP Pick of J.D. Vance, and Bide...
J.D. Vance's personal story of growing up in Appalachia, dealing with grave family turmoil, poverty, societal decay, abuse, family addiction, and eventually his path to a better life. It helped explain to coastal elites some of why Trump's message to the forgotten men and women of middle America, to working class Americans, helped propel him to victory.
My home, he writes in Hillbilly Elegy, was a hub of misery.
You got to read the book.
When I finished the book, I felt a little worried about you.
The book is not an effort to sort of finally work through all of these things that happened when I was a kid. It's the beginning of an effort that will probably take me for the rest of my life.
It's like, yeah, I love Trump, but like what?
Episode: Elon Musk Goes All In On Trump, and Predicting the...
J.D. Vance wrote the bestselling book Hillbilly Elegy, which was made into a film by Ron Howard and cast Glenn Close in the role of J.D.'s MAMA. Glenn Close was nominated for an Academy Award, a Golden Globe, and a Screen Actors Guild Award for her role in the movie.
So it appears that no good deed goes unpunished because even though JD Vance wrote this bestselling book Hail Belly Elegy that was made into a film by Ron Howard that cast Glenn Close in the iconic role of JD's MAMA.
Glenn Close is not grateful for any of those opportunities because by the way for which she was nominated for an Academy Award a Golden Globe and a Screen Actors Guild Award.
Episode: Harris Steals Trump's "No Tax on Tips" Plan, and N...
It was mentioned that J.D. Vance's book was discussed as part of the campaign against him and that he had made comments about 'childless cat ladies' in it, years prior.
They could choose to focus on that just as much as they focused on an old J.D. Vance comment on the Childless Cat Ladies.
Episode: Media Pushes Vibes Over Reality, and Walz "Stolen...
It was mentioned in the context of Tim Walz's campaign, contrasting his supposed 'heartland' appeal with J.D. Vance's background and the book's subject matter.
I think you got the Hillbilly Elegy against the real hillbilly.
Episode: The Important and Powerful New Movie "Reagan," wit...
Megyn Kelly mentioned the book "Hillbilly Elegy", written by J.D. Vance, and drew parallels between Usha, Vance's wife, and Nancy Reagan, in that they both played a significant and supportive role in the lives of their husbands.
Dennis I know has been reading Hillbilly Elegy by JD Vance.
I see a lot of parallels here in some ways between what Usha, JD's wife has done for him and what Nancy Reagan did for Ron.
Episode: Tulsi Endorses Trump in Political Realignment, and...
Vance mentioned that J.D. Vance has a hit best seller and a Hollywood film based on how poor he was as a kid growing up.
He's trying to out-come and he's trying to out-pour J.D. Vance who has a hit best seller and a Hollywood film based on how poor he was as a kid growing up.
Episode: Dems Disrespect Biden as They Kick Him Out, and Fa...
The speaker mentioned the book "Hillbilly Elegy" and commented that JD Vance's Hillbilly cousins did not go to Yale or become venture capitalists like Vance did. They also implied that the book's portrayal of Hillbilly culture was not an accurate representation of who people really are.
That angst that JD Bantz talks about in Hillbilly Elegy, none of my Hillbilly cousins went to Yale and none of them went on to be adventure capitalists or whatever.
It's not who people really are.
Episode: The Important and Powerful New Movie "Reagan," wit...
Megyn Kelly mentioned that Dennis Quaid had been reading "Hillbilly Elegy" and that she sees parallels between Usha, J.D.'s wife, and Nancy Reagan, as they both played a significant role in their husbands' lives.
Dennis I know has been reading "Hillbilly Elegy" by J.D. Vance.
I see a lot of parallels here in some ways between what Usha, J.D.'s wife has done for him and what Nancy Reagan did for Ron.
Episode: Tulsi Endorses Trump in Political Realignment, and...
J.D. Vance's book, 'Hillbilly Elegy,' was mentioned as being a bestseller and as the basis for a Hollywood film. It was said to be about his experience growing up poor.
and he's trying to out pour J.D. Vance who has a hit best seller and a Hollywood film based on how poor he was as a kid growing up
Episode: Dems Disrespect Biden as They Kick Him Out, and Fa...
It was mentioned how J.D. Vance's book 'Hillbilly Elegy' talks about the angst of people from Appalachia, but that none of his relatives went to Yale or became venture capitalists, so the book doesn't represent everyone's reality.
That angst that JD Bantz talks about in Hillbilly Elegy, none of my Hillbilly cousins went to Yale and none of them went on to be adventure capitalists or whatever. It's not who people really are.
It's not who people really are.
Episode: Trump Shakedown Exposed, and Loser Students Occupy...
Sheffield compares her story to J.D. Vance's Hillbilly Elegy, saying that Vance had many challenges with his nuclear family and that he had two really important influences: his sister Lindsay and his maternal grandmother. She states that her story is different, as she did not have someone like that to rely on.
This year when you held up the book it looks to me it kind of reminded me of J.D. Vance's Hillbilly Elegy and your story in some ways really reminds me of his story too where he had so many challenges in his nuclear family that he grew up in with his mother all sorts of issues there not to mention father figures and through it all he had two really important influences his sister Lindsay and his mama whose grandmother, his maternal grandmother and they made all the difference
Episode: Caitlin Clark Haters, and Trump's VP Apprentice an...
Megyn Kelly described it as a book that provided an insightful background into J.D. Vance and his family and was a memorable interview.
Go back and read his book Hillbilly Elegy...
...and I've said it's always been far my favorite interview I've ever done was of J.D. Vance in-depth at NBC.
Episode: Predators Exposed at Nickelodeon, and Democrats Ab...
It was used as a comparison for Batya Ungar-Sargon's book 'Second Class', in terms of the tone and the audience it's targeting, specifically working class people.
It's kind of like...it reminds you of JD Vance's Hillbilly, you know, it's kind of like that in its tone and who you're talking to.
Episode: Dems New Abortion Push, and SCOTUS Leaker Fallout,...
Megyn Kelly reminisced about an interview she conducted with J.D. Vance, highlighting his inspiring life story and his 'pick yourself up by the bootstraps' attitude, which was depicted in his book.
This remains my favorite interview I did while I was at NBC. It's just such a pick yourself up by the bootstraps and try to make life happen despite so many things being thrown at him story.
Episode: Putin Exploits Biden's Weakness and Canada's Autho...
It was mentioned as a book that details a childhood in poverty and how a person could have been pulled into a criminal element but instead chose a different path.
If you read his book, Hillbilly Elegy, which you must if you haven't met you, but America, a mixed race guy from Canada who grew up in a fatherless home and a Latino with Cuban-American roots who are pushing the solutions to that.
Episode: "Dopesick" - The Sackler Family: A Megyn Kelly Sho...
It was mentioned in comparison to Beth Macy's book 'Dopesick', in terms of its honest, sometimes unfavorable, but not critical view of Appalachia and its economic challenges.
It's not totally dissimilar from Hillbilly Elegy by JD Vance. It just takes a hard, honest and sometimes unfavorable view of Appalachia and what's happened there.
Episode: American Stories, with Bari Weiss, J.D. Vance, and...
The book and its film adaptation were discussed, focusing on the American dream's attainability and the learned helplessness in some communities. Reviewers criticized the movie for lacking diversity, while viewers seemed to appreciate its message.
He's getting killed, killed in the reviews, which was completely predictable.
But I read those reviews, and I think the movie was great. And I think, you know what? It's okay to go after deplorables again, and it's not okay to humanize them as he does.
Vance paints Appalachia as a near exclusively white space erased our black residents and their history in the region missing are the many generations of native American communities ignored is a growing Latino population disregarded are Appalachians who embrace racial justice and acceptance of their LGBTQ neighbors.
It's like, okay, so BIPOC is black indigenous people of color, LGBTQIA is lesbian, gender nonconforming, bisexual, transgender, intersex, asexual.
And I read this and I'm like, you people are crazy. Like truly the authentic, real Appalachians use these like 14 character pronouns every time they talk about themselves.
Episode: Adam Grant on How To Win Arguments, "Safe Spaces"...
Megyn Kelly mentioned the book and how its author was demonized for writing about the struggles of the white working class in Appalachia, highlighting the dangers of discriminatory practices based on race.
Well, you're not allowed to feel sympathy for them. Why? Because they have white skin.
Episode: Thomas Chatterton Williams on the Authoritarian Le...
It was brought up as an example of someone who overcame significant challenges to achieve success, suggesting that socioeconomic disadvantages should be considered in admissions, not just race.
I think about somebody like J.D. Vance, you know, who grew up in Appalachia and had a mother who was addicted to drugs and nobody in the family had ever been to college.
Episode: Amy Chua on the Climate on Campuses, Political Tri...
It was mentioned that Amy Chua had encouraged J.D. Vance, the author of the book, to write his memoir while he was a student at Yale Law School.
We met for the first time in person when I was doing a profile on JD Vance and I went to Yale Law School to talk to you as the person who had encouraged him as his professor to write that memoir.
Episode: Mike Rowe on Patriotism, the Value of Authenticity...
The movie adaptation of the book was mentioned and it was said that it received negative reviews, which were unsurprising, but the speaker personally felt the movie was good.
It's getting killed, killed in the reviews, which was completely predictable.
But I read those reviews and I think of the movie was great. And I think, you know what? It's okay to, it's okay to go after deplorables again. And it's, and it's not okay to humanize them as he does.
Episode: New Poll Panics Dems, Debate Preview, and Kamala's...
Ron Howard made a movie based on this book, and later criticized the author's political positions.
I have been surprised and, you know, and concerned by a lot of the rhetoric, you know, coming out of that campaign given the experience that I had then five, six years ago.
I'm very surprised and disappointed by much of the rhetoric I'm reading and hearing. People do change and I assume that's the case.
Episode: Best of the Week: ABC's Terrible Debate Moderators...
Ron Howard made a movie based on this book a few years ago. He later expressed surprise and disappointment at J.D. Vance's more recent political rhetoric.
He made, he made the movie Hillbilly Elegy a couple of years ago based on J.D. Vance's bestselling book and good for him for making the movie.
I have been surprised and, you know, and, and concerned by a lot of the rhetoric, you know, coming out of that campaign.
Episode: New Poll Panics Dems, Debate Preview, and Kamala's...
The hosts noted that Ron Howard had turned JD Vance's bestselling memoir into a movie, referring to it as a notable work in the discussion.
He made the movie Hillbilly Elegy a couple of years ago based on JD Vance bestselling book and good for him for making the movie even though at that point we knew that JD Vance you know seem to be more Republican leaning but more of a Trump whisperer at that point who could explain the white working class as opposed to you know it's fine to be a Republican as long as you're never Trump Republican.
Episode: New Tim Walz Lies and China Connection, and Trump'...
The podcast mentioned J.D. Vance's book, referencing its depiction of his personal experiences and how it might humanize him to voters. It was mentioned in relation to his persona and public image.
And I'm not sure what else we should put on our drinking bingo card, but give us some thought and I'll come back to you after the break.
Episode: New Tim Walz Lies and China Connection, and Trump'...
The podcast mentioned J.D. Vance's book, referencing its portrayal of his background and the movie adaptation. It was used to humanize him and connect with the audience.
I will say if J.D. Vance does not mention the name Mamaw, I will fall off of my sofa.
Humanizing and a great personality who millions of Americans know, thanks to his book Hillbilly Elegy and the movie,