So Supernatural

The Long-Lost Friend, a 19th-century American grimoire, was featured during the discussion of the Hex Hollow Murder, where the hosts detailed its infamous history. The book was discussed not as a literary work, but as a highly sought-after magical object believed to grant incredible supernatural protection. The podcast highlighted historical quotes claiming that whoever carried the book would be safe from all enemies, immune to unnatural death, and protected from unjust legal sentences, explaining why John Blymeier and his accomplices desperately sought to obtain it.

Professor John E Mack's comprehensive work, Passport to the Cosmos, was highlighted as a foundational text investigating extraterrestrial encounters and their psychological impact. The book, published in 1999, included the Ariel School sighting discussed in the episode as part of its sweeping analysis. The hosts noted Mack's investigative approach, which emphasized the need to "listen, sift and consider alternative explanations" when reviewing these profound experiences.

The book was brought up during a conspiracy‑focused episode, where the hosts explained that the 1975 trilogy had gathered and exaggerated classic Illuminati lore. They noted that, despite being fiction, it had led many readers to believe the secret society was still manipulating world events. The discussion was neutral, treating the work as a cultural touchstone rather than a recommendation.

The Mystery of the Cathedrals, published under the pen name Fulcanelli, was discussed for its alleged connections to alchemical lore and the historical figure Nicolas Flamel. The podcast noted that the text supposedly encodes ancient secrets through symbolism and metaphor hidden within cathedral architecture. While fascinating in concept, it was described as a notably difficult read.

The podcast discussed The Voyage of the Norman D. in the context of author Barbara Newhall Follett's unusual life and eventual disappearance. This novel, published when she was just 14, was noted for being based on her real-life experiences serving as a cabin boy aboard a lumber ship. While the book achieved success, the hosts mentioned that Follett was unable to celebrate due to her father’s departure from the family.

Host Ashley Flowers explicitly recommended John G. Fuller's Incident at Exeter, noting it was an extremely helpful resource for their investigation into the famous UFO encounter. The book was highlighted not only for its detailed information but also for its historical significance, having revived national interest in the Exeter case following its 1966 publication.

The Origin of Species was mentioned strictly as a historical timestamp during a discussion about paranormal folklore and vampire beliefs. The hosts noted that the book's 1859 publication coincided precisely with the period when Americans began exhuming bodies suspected of being vampires in New England, serving only as a chronological marker.

Robert Fabian's memoir, Fabian of the Yard, was cited as a critical primary source document during the discussion of the Charles Walton murder. Fabian, a Scotland Yard detective on the case, devoted an entire chapter to the investigation. Crucially, the book was noted for being the first public record where a police official mentioned the involvement of witchcraft in the notorious case.

In the episode, the hosts examined the book's investigation of the Charles Walton murder, noting its 1968 publication and its suggestion of a witchcraft connection supported by a high priestess’s account and an anonymous source. The discussion was informational rather than endorsing, highlighting the book’s unique perspective on the case.

This folklore guide was highlighted during the discussion of the notorious Charles Walton murder case. The book was crucial to the investigation, as Detective Fabian reportedly utilized its insights into the superstitious beliefs and old customs prevalent in the Cotswolds region. It allowed the detective to understand and interpret the unusual behavior of the local villagers during the inquiry.

Dennis Deitz's exploration of the famous Greenbrier Ghost case was featured when the podcast covered the murder conviction secured by ghostly testimony. The book was highlighted for its detailed research, particularly the author's discovery that contemporary newspaper articles may have inspired the supernatural elements of the story. It was presented as an essential resource for those interested in the historical specifics of the case.

While investigating the origins of the creature, Ashley Flowers cited Brian Regal's book, The Secret History of the Jersey Devil, as a source. The hosts specifically discussed Regal’s theory suggesting the creature might be connected to the Tarsus pterodactyl. However, this claim was brought up mainly to be analyzed and was ultimately noted to have significant inconsistencies.

The book was referenced as a source on mass hysteria to explain the Jersey Devil sightings as a collective delusion, with the host noting its perspective on how such phenomena affect small, powerless groups. The discussion was brief and used the title mainly to illustrate the concept.

In a single episode, the hosts discussed the title, noting that it was published in 1957 and presented a harsh critique of the original authors, labeling their experience as a delusion tied to their romantic relationship. They highlighted that modern critics viewed the work as homophobic, and it was presented more as a point of criticism than a recommendation.

The episode highlighted the title as a 2019 work that argued the disappearance was the result of a sophisticated hijacking rather than an accident. It noted the author's claim that satellite pings were deliberately misleading, creating a false trail for investigators. The discussion presented these theories without overt endorsement.

The hosts noted that the title had reached number one on the New York Times bestseller list and that its author, a neurosurgeon, claimed to have spoken with God and interacted with angelic beings while in a medically induced coma. They highlighted these extraordinary claims as the reason it was brought up in the discussion.

In the episode the hosts noted that the book had become a bestseller and recounted the author's claim of communicating with seraphic beings after a near‑fatal kayak accident. They highlighted the near‑death experience as the central focus of the narrative. The overall tone was more of a brief mention rather than a strong endorsement.

The book was highlighted for its commercial success, noting that it had sold over a million copies and was adapted into a TV movie. However, the discussion turned critical when it was revealed that the author later confessed the entire narrative was fabricated. The episode used this revelation to caution listeners about the credibility of such accounts.