The Man from the Train: The Solving of a Century-Old Serial Killer Mystery Cover
Podcast Mentions

The Man from the Train The Solving of a Century-Old Serial Killer Mystery

Bill James

An Edgar Award finalist for Best Fact Crime, this “impressive…open-eyed investigative inquiry wrapped within a cultural history of rural America” ( Between 1898 and 1912, families across the country were bludgeoned in their sleep with the blunt side of an axe. Jewelry and valuables were left in pla...

Podcasts 2
Quotes 32
Morbid

Podcast

Morbid

The hosts said the book offered a solid theory and they strongly recommended it for further listening.

"

That was according to The Man from the Train by Bill James, which is such a good book. And he's a retired detective who like goes into this case and looks at it from a detective's point of view from n...

— Episode: Episode 271: The Villisca Axe Murders Pa...

Episode: Episode 271: The Villisca Axe Murders Part 1

The hosts said the book offered a solid theory and they strongly recommended it for further listening.

"

That was according to The Man from the Train by Bill James, which is such a good book. And he's a retired detective who like goes into this case and looks at it from a detective's point of view from now.

I highly, highly recommend that book. I'll link it.

Episode: Episode 272: The Villisca Axe Murders Part 2

The hosts repeatedly urged listeners to purchase the book, describing it as a lengthy, fastreading truecrime work that covers numerous axemurder cases.

"

And according to the book The Man from the Train by Bill James, which I can't say it enough. Go buy that book.

I'm not kidding you. Go buy the book. It'll just, you won't stop. You will just blow through those. Just keeps coming and it just keeps coming.

According to the man from the train, read it again. Love that book.

Bill James in his book says that often this particular serial killer would kill everyone in their sleep and they would be found where they lay.

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

The hosts repeatedly praised the book as a fact‑dense, horrifying true‑crime narrative that uncovered a serial killer linking dozens of early‑20th‑century axe murders. Karen and Georgia highlighted its thorough research and engaging storytelling, noting the author’s unique background and recommending it as essential listening for true‑crime fans. They called it one of their favorite titles and urged listeners to read it.

Highly Recommended

Episode: 295 - Twenty-Two To Go

It was described as factually dense yet horrifying and a story that many people had never heard of before. It was strongly recommended by Karen as a true crime read.

"

For someone who loves this book so much, I fuck it up a lot.

But that book is by the author Bill James and his daughter, Rachel McCarthy James.

And if you are looking for a true crime book that is going to be factually dense and yet absolutely horrifying as a story where you think, oh, my God, how do I never know about this? Read the man from the train.

I will keep on recommending it until year 28 of this podcast.

Episode: 265 - The Answer’s Salt

It was described as a favorite book of one of the podcasters' friends, who also recommended another true crime book called "Last Call".

"

OK, I have another book recommendation, but I took this one from our friend of the family, Rachel McCarthy James, who is the co-author of my favorite, favorite book, The Man From the Train.

If you haven't read The Man From the Train and you like true crime, it is. Stop yelling at my mind blowing. I just want to reread it.

Episode: 168 – Live at the Civic Center in Des Moines

It was discussed as a book that presented a theory about a possible serial killer in the late 1800s and early 1900s, potentially connected to the Villisca Axe Murders.

"

I have recommended this book now so many times it's called the man from the train it's um by bill james and he's uh yeah he's an analyst he writes a lot about baseball but he wrote this book and um uh so he basically he has this theory there have been axe murders of families in homes around the united states from 1898 through 1912 and in so i will now list the similarities oh god oh god of the man from the trains mo and to the villisca axe murders i'm buying this book immediately it's such a good book i never listened to you before but no i see

it's called the man from the train it links it all up and that is the unbelievable and still unsolved villisca axe murder story amazing great fucking job thank you kindly

Episode: MFM Minisode 199

It was discussed as a favorite true crime book, highlighting the concept of someone entering a small town and causing devastation before disappearing, emphasizing how easy it was to blend in during that era.

"

To a horrible and mysterious, this makes me want to point back to once again one of my favorite true crime books of all time, The Man from the Train, which is unbelievable.

And it has that thing where the idea that someone comes into a small town where people are just the assumption of safety because they're far away from people, they're away from the big city or whatever and decimates a family and then just walks away and nothing ever happens from that is just crazy.

I feel like back then it was just so easy to just blend in and be a nameless, faceless person going through town.

Yeah, that's crazy. And you could hop on trains again.

Read The Man from the Train if you're that. So good.

Episode: 215 - Three Small Hot Dogs

It was strongly recommended by Georgia for its entertaining and captivating true crime content, and she noted that the author, Rachel McCarthy James, is believed to be a listener of the show.

"

If you haven't read the man on a train and you're looking for quarantine entertainment, I know I've recommended it a hundred times, but it is a. I still haven't read it.

That book's amazing.

Episode: 106 - Courage Shoulders

It was highly recommended for its unique approach to true crime, specifically its linking of multiple murders to one person using train travel.

"

It's called the man from the train by a man who's normally a baseball writer named Bill James, but he also wrote the book popular crime.

So he's linking the Velasca acts murders and a bunch of other really grisly murders. It's one guy that used to ride the train and it's just incredible.

They did so much research.

It's one of those really satisfying, like if you know about this crime and this crime and this crime, he's like, it's all one guy.

Episode: 168 – Live at the Civic Center in Des Moines

It was discussed as a possible explanation for the Villisca Axe Murders, suggesting a pattern of similar family axe murders across the US around the turn of the 20th century, possibly by the same perpetrator.

"

I have recommended this book now so many times it's called the man from the train it's um by Bill James and he's uh yeah he's an analyst he writes a lot about baseball but he wrote this book and um uh so he basically he has this theory there have been axe murders of families in homes around the united states from 1898 through 1912 and in so i will now list the similarities oh god oh god of the man from the trains mo and to the villisca axe murders i'm buying this book immediately it's such a good book i never listened to you before but no i see

it's called the man from the train it links it all up and that is the unbelievable and still unsolved villisca axe murder story amazing great fucking job thank you kindly

Episode: 106 - Courage Shoulders

It was highly recommended due to its engaging narrative and clear research linking various grisly murders to one person who rode the train.

"

It's called the man from the train by a man who's normally a baseball writer named Bill James, but he also wrote the book popular crime.

So he's linking the Velasca acts murders and a bunch of other really grisly murders. It's one guy that used to ride the train and it's just incredible.

They did so much research.

And also the way he writes, like sometimes I feel like when I read true crime books, it's very like, uh, it gets very prosy and like kind of like the very overly descriptive this guy. It's like, he's just talking to you or he was like, well, we'll talk about that later.

It's really cool narrative and then it's just really clear. And it's one of those really satisfying, like if you know about this crime and this crime and this crime, he's like, it's all one guy.

Note: The book recommendations on this page are discovered automatically from podcast transcripts, and may be incorrect or incomplete.