Inventing the Pinkertons; or, Spies, Sleuths, Mercenaries, and Thugs: Being a story of the nation’s most famous (and infamous) detective agency Cover
Podcast Mentions

Inventing the Pinkertons; or, Spies, Sleuths, Mercenaries, and Thugs Being a story of the nation’s most famous (and infamous) detective agency

S. Paul O'Hara

The fascinating story of the most notorious detective agency in US history. Between 1865 and 1937, Pinkerton’s National Detective Agency was at the center of countless conflicts between capital and labor, bandits and railroads, and strikers and state power. Some believed that the detectives were pr...

Podcasts 2
Quotes 10
Behind the Bastards

This book was referenced multiple times when talking about the Pinkerton Detective Agency, its history, and its history of violence against striking workers.

"

by the end of June, he had built around the mills, a protective 12-foot fence that included rifle holes, water mains capable of blasting strikers with boiling water and wires attached to a generator,...

— Episode: It Could Happen Here Weekly 81

Episode: It Could Happen Here Weekly 81

This book was referenced multiple times when talking about the Pinkerton Detective Agency, its history, and its history of violence against striking workers.

"

by the end of June, he had built around the mills, a protective 12-foot fence that included rifle holes, water mains capable of blasting strikers with boiling water and wires attached to a generator, which could be electrified.

This serious battle would last the next 14 hours. After an initial surge, the Pinkertons were pinned down in their barges. After several hours, the crowd attempted to sink the barges by cannon fire.

Residents borrowed the cannon that had been, that the city used for commemorations.

The crowd also sent burning rail cars rolling towards the barges and sprayed oil into the river, which they attempted to light on fire in hopes of burning the Pinkertons out of their barges.

That is a phase of our business that we are not particularly delighted or proud of and we're out of it. However, there was nothing illegal about it at the time.

American History Tellers

The author initially intended to write a straightforward history of the Pinkertons but discovered that the company's obsession with its reputation and mythology was a more interesting story. He decided to tell the story of the story of the Pinkertons, uncovering the ways in which they crafted their image and controlled the narrative.

"

I think like any historian, you find something interesting, you find these key peoples moving through this historical landscape and you want to know more about them, right?

— Episode: The Pinkerton Detective Agency | Behind...

Episode: The Pinkerton Detective Agency | Behind The Brand...

The author initially intended to write a straightforward history of the Pinkertons but discovered that the company's obsession with its reputation and mythology was a more interesting story. He decided to tell the story of the story of the Pinkertons, uncovering the ways in which they crafted their image and controlled the narrative.

"

I think like any historian, you find something interesting, you find these key peoples moving through this historical landscape and you want to know more about them, right?

I did what every other historian does, which is you go to the archives, you look at the documents.

I knew all the legends, I knew all the folktales.

The more I looked, I went to the archives, I went to the Library of Congress, I went to the company files hoping to find those really juicy details and they just weren't there.

And the more I looked, the more I found that in the archives, in their records, the company records, it was just this obsessive detailing of their reputation.

Note: The book recommendations on this page are discovered automatically from podcast transcripts, and may be incorrect or incomplete.