Anarchy, State, and Utopia

"

And this you could see very clearly in a wonderful book by Robert Gnossick called anarchy state and utopia which explains how the state emerges but strictly speaking

"

Individuals have rights and there are things no person or group may do to them.

The only way you'd owe them money is if you consented to pay them for the music before they started playing.

This is of course in direct contrast to the long tradition of political philosophy being centered around utilitarianism.

The book Anarchy, State, and Utopia offers a unique argument in favor of libertarianism, which at the time was in many ways a different solution to 20th century political problems that were going on.

It's been said that while Nozick offers a defensive libertarianism from the perspective of rights, Hayek offers a defensive libertarianism from the perspective of markets.

"

And he says one of the examples that really made him realize this during this period in his life was a thought experiment put out by the philosopher Robert Nozick in his famous book called Anarchy, State and Utopia.

"

Have you ever heard of Bob Nozick?

I was reading about this thought experiment that he came up with.

It was such an interesting hypothetical.

It was called the experience machine.

So Nozick asked, and I think this was 1974, and I remember noting the date around when he said this because he didn't say this in 2024, right?

So in 1974, Nozick says, imagine there's an experience machine.

And when you plug yourself into the experience machine, it's like you're kind of just like a brain liquid and basically you experience pleasure, but not just like some blunt force pleasure.

It's like you can have these like vivid experiences of having written the great American novel, having the perfect family.

One could fill in the blank being a triathlete, but also a unicorn billionaire or whatever.

So that's the experience machine.

You plug in and it gives you this vicarious sensation that you are living your best life.

And the puzzle or the question, the dilemma, whatever you want to call it is, do you choose to plug in or not?

And Nozick is like, that's pretty simple.

Who would choose to plug into the experience machine?

And then he goes on to say, it's like, because what is carriage if not like actually taking, you know, charge of your life and like taking real risks?

It's like, what is love and what are relationships unless they're real and difficult and so forth.

And I think in 2024, we have a kind of stunning answer to his question, which is, oh yeah, we choose to plug into the experience machine all the time.

And I wish Bob Nozick were alive today to ask it again, because I think he would have to reckon with the reality that like, well, like for example, Bob, people are on their screens like about as many hours as they're sleeping today.

"

Angela was likely thinking of the thought experiment described by American philosopher Robert Nozick in his 1974 book Anarchy, State and Utopia.

in the book humans have the choice to experience reality as it exists or to live forever in a pleasant simulation Nozick posited that most people would choose not to plug into the pleasure machine he died in 2002

"

Angela was likely thinking of the thought experiment described by American philosopher Robert Nozick in his 1974 book, Anarchy, State and Utopia.

In the book, humans have the choice to experience reality as it exists or to live forever in a pleasant simulation.

Nozick posited that most people would choose not to plug into the pleasure machine.